AN EXPERIMENTAL STUDY TO MANAGE PRE- AND POST-OPERATIVE STRESS, DEPRESSION AND ANXIETY AMONG ADULTS UNDERGOING ORTHOPEDIC SURGERY
Background. Psychological distress is common around orthopedic trauma surgery and predicts pain, delayed mobilization and poorer recovery. In Pakistan, where motorbike crashes generate a large share of tibia fractures in young working adults, structured psychological support is rarely part of public-hospital orthopedic care. Aim. To evaluate whether a nurse-led programme combining structured education with the Benson relaxation technique, delivered across the pre- and early post-operative periods, reduces stress, anxiety and depression in adults undergoing operative fixation of a tibia fracture. Methods. A multicentre, two-arm, parallel-group randomized controlled trial was conducted in the orthopedic wards of four tertiary hospitals in South Punjab, Pakistan. Sixty-four adults aged 18 to 55 years were randomized within hospital to six nurse-led sessions of education and Benson relaxation plus routine care (n = 32) or routine care alone (n = 32). The Urdu Depression Anxiety Stress Scales (DASS-21) were administered at admission and on post-operative day 4. Between-group effects were estimated with analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) adjusted for baseline scores, and change over time with a two-wave multilevel growth model. Results. All randomized participants completed follow-up. Groups were comparable at baseline. After adjustment, the intervention group had lower post-test depression (adjusted mean difference −5.46, 95% CI −8.63 to −2.30, partial η² = .16), anxiety (−5.95, 95% CI −9.62 to −2.29, partial η² = .15) and stress (−5.27, 95% CI −8.72 to −1.82, partial η² = .13) than controls, all p ≤ .003. The adjusted difference in total score was −16.66 points (95% CI −23.11 to −10.21, partial η² = .30), and the direction of benefit was the same in all four hospitals. The growth model confirmed a steeper decline in the intervention group for depression, anxiety and stress (Time × Group b = −5.69, −6.81 and −4.94; p = .003, < .001 and .011). The proportion with moderate or worse depression at post-test was 18.8% with the intervention and 56.3% with routine care. Conclusion. A brief, low-cost, nurse-led Benson relaxation and education programme spanning the perioperative period produced clinically meaningful reductions in depression, anxiety and stress after tibia fracture surgery and is feasible for scale-up in public hospitals. Keywords: Benson relaxation; perioperative anxiety; depression; tibia fracture; nurse-led intervention; randomized controlled trial; Pakistan
Authors
- Perspectives in Social Sciences
Publication Details
- Journal
- Perspectives in Social Sciences
- Published
- 2026-11-14
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24223966
- Primary Topic
- Music Therapy and Health
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00