The Boundaries of Clowning and Recognition through Silence: Anticipatory Self-Negation and the Aesthetics of Trust in Osamu Dazai's No Longer Human
Overview This paper offers a philosophical and aesthetic reinterpretation of clowning in Osamu Dazai's No Longer Human (1948). It examines how Yōzō's deliberate self-ridicule may function as a means of controlling the scope of others' judgements, while concealing the desperate effort to preserve a final boundary of self-respect. Introducing the concepts of the "menu of permissible judgements", "second-order shame", and "recognition through silence", the paper explores the distinction between detecting another person's vulnerability and using that knowledge to define or condemn them. Through close readings of the novel and a limited comparison with research on banter, it develops an aesthetics of trust grounded in interpretative restraint rather than complete understanding or unconditional affirmation. Abstract This paper rereads the clowning of Ōba Yōzō in Osamu Dazai’s No Longer Human (1948) as a form of anticipatory self-negation that pre-empts negative judgements by others and restricts their objects. The failures and absurdities offered through clowning can function as a kind of menu of permissible judgements, selecting in advance what others are invited to evaluate. Yet what the subject seeks to conceal is not simply a defect but the desperation with which he attempts to protect his self-respect by offering such defects for scrutiny. This paper describes the double structure as second-order shame and reads Takeichi’s detection of Yōzō’s performance in contrast with Yōzō’s subsequent voluntary disclosure of a self-portrait. It also examines the judgements framed by the novel’s preface and postscript, Yoshiko’s “innocent trust”, and the breakdown of joking exchanges with Horiki, before making a limited comparison with research on banter. The resulting notion of recognition through silence does not require that another person fail to detect a defence. Rather, it describes a refusal to use what has been detected to pronounce a final judgement on the person as a whole. Such recognition is not identical to reciprocal trust between actual persons; it characterises instead a restraint in judgement available to readers of a narrative of self-negation, and identifies conditions under which an aesthetics of trust may arise. Language and Version Note This record contains two parallel-language versions of the same scholarly work: the original Japanese manuscript and its English translation. The Japanese version serves as the original text, while the English version is provided for international academic accessibility. Both versions present the same central argument, conceptual framework, and textual analysis, and should be treated as a single scholarly work rather than separate publications. This is the first public version (v1.0, November 2026). Both language versions are archived together under the same Zenodo DOI.
Authors
- Suzume Suzume
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-14
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24215282
- Primary Topic
- Ethics, Aesthetics, and Art
- Type
- preprint