Milton's “Malignant” Reader: Edward Lightborne, 1647
The Stillingfleet collection at Marsh's Library in Dublin holds a leather-bound Sammelband under shelfmark E1.5.26 consisting of six works by Milton: the expanded 1644 edition of the Doctrine and Discipline of Divorce, Colasterion, The Judgement of Martin Bucer, Tetrachordon, Areopagitica, and Of Education, in that order. 1 The pastedown features the inscription "Edward Lightbourne his Booke 1647" along with the price mark "0-2-4," i.e., two shillings and four pence.This information provides sufficient evidence to establish the probable identity of a previously unknown early collectorand presumably reader-of Milton's prose.Records indicate that Edward Lightborne (or Lightbourne) was admitted as an exhibitioner at St. Paul's School in London in 1630 and matriculated as a sizar at Clare College (then Clare Hall), Cambridge in Easter term 1631 (Gardiner 36; Venn and Venn 3.1: 84).The description of Lightborne as an exhibitioner, or scholarship-winner, and a sizar, who served other students to cover his fees, implies that he required financial support for his studies.Lightborne received his BA from Clare in 1635 and proceeded MA in 1639; his affiliation two years earlier with Queen's College, Oxford suggests that he incorporated his degree at the other university.There are some obvious similarities with Milton's own educational background-Milton, too, studied at St. Paul's and Cambridge and may have incorporated his degree at Oxford-and Lightborne's matriculation at Clare in Easter term 1631 means that they briefly overlapped at Cambridge since Milton did not graduate MA until July 1632.Within a few years of the conclusion of his studies, Lightborne found employment at the parish church of St. John the Baptist in Westfield, Sussex, but on 6 October 1646 the Committee for Plundered Ministers removed him "for drunkenness & malignancy" and the following April "ordered him to let sequors have all books &c.belonging to living" (Matthews 359; see also Sawyer 154-55).A subsequent order on 28 May 1647 stipulated that he was to be replaced by "Fflorice Cooke a godlie & orthodox Divine" (Sawyer 155).Drunkenness was a common pretext for the dismissal of ideologically dubious clergy, and the language of "malignancy" characterizes Lightborne as an enemy of Parliament and godly religion (see Leng on the term).Of particular interest is the comment that "all books &c.belonging to living" were to pass to Lightborne's successor.The loss of books and manuscripts was frequently lamented by evicted ministers (see McCall 112-13 et passim), and there might have been little distinction observed between Lightborne's own library and the books that officially belonged to the parish living.Lightborne's whereabouts thereafter are unknown until his burial at St. Michael Paternoster Royal in London on 20 March 1659/60.He died mere weeks before the Restoration of Charles 2, thereby missing the opportunity to petition for his former living.Walker Revised further notes that his long-lived widow, Ann, received relief from the Corporation of the Sons of the Clergy until 1721, the "last widow of a seqd.minr.left on the roll" (Matthews 359).
Authors
- Thomas Matthew Vozar (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1718-2616)
Institutions
- University of Florida (US)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Milton Quarterly
- Published
- 2026-11-14
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.1111/milt.70037
- Primary Topic
- Libraries, Manuscripts, and Books
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00