Productive Struggle vs. Cognitive Overload: A Quantitative Analysis of Grade 7 Students’ Performance on Complex Mathematical Tasks
This quantitative descriptive-correlational study examined whether Grade 7 students’ engagement with complex MATATAG-aligned mathematical tasks reflected productive struggle or cognitive overload, and how these cognitive constructs relate to problem-solving performance. Using a purposive cluster sampling technique, data were collected from 272 Grade 7 students in a public secondary school. Participants completed a 20-item Productive Struggle Scale, a 20-item Multidimensional Cognitive Load Scale, and a 15-item criterion-referenced Problem-Solving Test. Descriptive results indicated high levels of perceived productive struggle and moderate cognitive load, yet students demonstrated extremely low problem-solving performance. Spearman rank-correlation analyses revealed no statistically significant relationship between productive struggle and performance, nor between cognitive load and performance. The quantitative findings challenge assumptions regarding the direct, positive transfer of effortful struggle into problem-solving performance in under-resourced contexts without explicit instructional heuristics. The study offers empirical implications for MATATAG curriculum implementation, task design, and Philippine mathematics instruction aligned with Sustainable Development Goal 4.
Authors
- Genesis Gabion Camarista
- Sarah C. Sabico
- Delmier D. Jimenez
- Mary O. Davales
- Ryan C. Alarios
Institutions
- West Visayas State University (PH)
Publication Details
- Journal
- International Journal of Research and Innovation in Applied Science
- Published
- 2026-11-13
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.51584/ijrias.2026.11100086
- Primary Topic
- Mathematics Education and Pedagogy
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00