Beyond objectivity: supervisory subjectivities, power dynamics, and their impact on doctoral students’ Scopus publication trajectories

Doctoral supervision is widely theorised as a mentoring relationship calibrated by academic standards and scholarly objectivity, yet the subjective dimensions of supervisory practice – including ideological orientations, relational preferences, and gate-keeping dispositions – remain systematically underexamined in the context of Scopus-indexed publication outcomes. This critical interpretive study investigated how supervisory subjectivities and power dynamics shaped the Scopus publication trajectories of 16 doctoral students across three public and private universities in East Java, Indonesia, where Scopus publication is required as a condition of degree conferral. Drawing on Foucault’s concept of disciplinary power and Bourdieu’s notion of academic capital as interpretive lenses applied after empirical categories had been developed, semi-structured in-depth interviews with candidates and supervisors and reflexive document analysis were conducted over twelve months, with data analysed through constructivist grounded theory. Findings revealed four analytically distinct supervisory disposition types – the Scholarly Gatekeeper, the Strategic Enabler, the Dependent Patron, and the Bureaucratic Compliant – each generating differential publication trajectories, affective consequences, and identity effects for doctoral candidates. Gatekeeping practices embedded in supervisor feedback, co-authorship norms, journal selection decisions, and revision-response protocols emerged as primary mechanisms through which power asymmetries were reproduced and contested. The study advances a Supervisory Capital Framework that reframes publication support as a relational and political accomplishment rather than a technically neutral mentoring function, and shows how a publication requirement mediates supervisory power in doctoral formation (learning, autonomy, and identity), and informs supervision policy, supervisor development, and institutional accountability in Indonesian and comparable Global South contexts.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Studies in Higher Education
Published
2026-11-13
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1080/03075079.2026.2764326
Primary Topic
Doctoral Education Challenges and Solutions
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Beyond objectivity: supervisory subjectivities, power dynamics, and their impact on doctoral students’ Scopus publication trajectories

Joko Slamet, Abd. Syakur
Studies in Higher Education
Doctoral Education Challenges and Solutions
article

Beyond objectivity: supervisory subjectivities, power dynamics, and their impact on doctoral students’ Scopus publication trajectories

Joko Slamet, Abd. Syakur
article en

Abstract

Doctoral supervision is widely theorised as a mentoring relationship calibrated by academic standards and scholarly objectivity, yet the subjective dimensions of supervisory practice – including ideological orientations, relational preferences, and gate-keeping dispositions – remain systematically underexamined in the context of Scopus-indexed publication outcomes. This critical interpretive study investigated how supervisory subjectivities and power dynamics shaped the Scopus publication trajectories of 16 doctoral students across three public and private universities in East Java, Indonesia, where Scopus publication is required as a condition of degree conferral. Drawing on Foucault’s concept of disciplinary power and Bourdieu’s notion of academic capital as interpretive lenses applied after empirical categories had been developed, semi-structured in-depth interviews with candidates and supervisors and reflexive document analysis were conducted over twelve months, with data analysed through constructivist grounded theory. Findings revealed four analytically distinct supervisory disposition types – the Scholarly Gatekeeper, the Strategic Enabler, the Dependent Patron, and the Bureaucratic Compliant – each generating differential publication trajectories, affective consequences, and identity effects for doctoral candidates. Gatekeeping practices embedded in supervisor feedback, co-authorship norms, journal selection decisions, and revision-response protocols emerged as primary mechanisms through which power asymmetries were reproduced and contested. The study advances a Supervisory Capital Framework that reframes publication support as a relational and political accomplishment rather than a technically neutral mentoring function, and shows how a publication requirement mediates supervisory power in doctoral formation (learning, autonomy, and identity), and informs supervision policy, supervisor development, and institutional accountability in Indonesian and comparable Global South contexts.

Studies in Higher Education
Cipta Wacana University (ID), Universitas PGRI Delta (ID)
Doctoral Education Challenges and Solutions
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon