How normative claims guide engineers under value pluralism: The “Portasello” model of collaborative viability and value interfaces
How can normative claims guide engineers under conditions of value pluralism? Existing approaches in the engineering and engineering management literatures, including value engineering, value management, and value-sensitive design, explain how values inform decision-making but leave underdeveloped how practitioners act when multiple legitimate values remain in tension. This paper develops a contextual account of action guidance drawing on Raz's theory of exclusionary reasons, Tomasello's account of socially stratified intentionality, and a conception of engineering as participation in collaborative value chains derived from Porter. It argues that engineers confront value pluralism not by resolving conflicts through value ranking or optimization, but committing to a higher-order norm of collaborative viability, which functions as a constitutive condition of engineering collaboration rather than as a competing substantive value. Building on this insight, the paper introduces the “Portasello” model, a framework of how engineers organize, communicate, and reconcile values through the management of intra-agent and inter-agent value interfaces. The model shows how values acquire action guiding force within collaborative practice by being translated into workable courses of action through coordination across the value chain. Rather than treating engineering as the application or pursuit of pre-given values, the paper reconceptualizes engineering as a practice of interface management through which diverse values become actionable. The framework further develops a typology of normative failure modes and argues that knowledge of how to sustain collaboration under conditions of persistent value pluralism constitutes a core dimension of engineering expertise.
Authors
- Martin Baumers (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9003-7760)
Publication Details
- Journal
- SocArXiv (OSF Preprints)
- Published
- 2026-11-14
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.31235/osf.io/ujfyn_v1
- Primary Topic
- Education, Technology, and Ethics
- Type
- preprint