Simulation-based techno-economic evaluation of triboelectric and electromagnetic footstep energy harvesting
Abstract Footstep energy harvesters must be evaluated by stored energy, mechanical input, power-management losses, and cost rather than by open-circuit voltage alone. This study developed a reproducible simulation framework for comparing electromagnetic, triboelectric, and hybrid floor-tile energy harvesters under a common 7.0 J gross footstep-energy budget. A reduced-order two-dimensional Finite Element Method Magnetics (FEMM) model, coil/load optimization, rectifier modeling, mechanical-energy checks, and an upfront prototype component-cost model were used for the electromagnetic generator (EMG). A nylon/polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) contact-separation triboelectric nanogenerator (TENG) was audited for active area, air breakdown, parasitic capacitance, leakage, high-voltage (HV) rectification, and shared mechanical input. The balanced EMG design used a 28-magnet alternating-radial array, American Wire Gauge (AWG) 32 coil with 1226 turns, Schottky rectification, and a modeled gear-ratio-80 scenario, producing 0.5507 J per simulated step and 0.00331 J per step per USD. A unit-consistent Paschen calculation gave a 19.48 kV uniform-field limit for the 5 mm TENG case; the audited TENG stored 0.002382 J per cycle. With one TENG cycle per EMG step, a realistic EMG-primary hybrid stored 0.552620 J per step, increasing stored energy by 0.346% but reducing energy per upfront dollar to 0.00214 J per step per USD. An illustrative coupling sensitivity showed that an additional mechanical penalty above 0.346% would erase this energy increment. A literature-bounded non-contact rotational TENG benchmark stored 0.001487 J per step under explicitly transferred assumptions; its mechanical allocation was not estimated because matching torque and mechanical-input data were unavailable. Under the modeled contact-separation geometry, conditioning assumptions, shared mechanical input, and prototype cost model, the studied TENG did not provide sufficient incremental stored energy to justify its addition for energy generation; this architecture-specific result does not generalize to all TENG designs.
Authors
- Vivek Nadella
- Ishaan Ghai
- Vismay Patel
Publication Details
- Journal
- Discover Electronics
- Published
- 2026-11-15
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.1007/s44291-026-00315-7
- Primary Topic
- Innovative Energy Harvesting Technologies
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00