Shared Nonlocal-Game Probes for Small Quantum Workloads: IBM Mirror Comparisons and Cross-Vendor Coverage Tests
Can a small set of shared nonlocal-game probes stand in for one mirror circuit per workload when screening small quantum workloads? We evaluate shared-probe screening (SPS): eight GHZ/Mermin echo circuits reused across workloads, a frozen simulator-trained predictor and a suite-level residual-quantile lower bound. The target is computational-basis output-distribution quality (a Hellinger proxy), not state fidelity. Direct SPS-versus-mirror comparisons were run on IBM processors only; IQM and Rigetti runs test bound coverage. (a) On 132 IBM links in three jobs, at equal screening shots, mirrors ranked workloads better (per-circuit Spearman 0.678 vs 0.487; difference −0.191, 95% CI [−0.283, −0.115]); this replicated on a fresh calibration day (88 links, two jobs; −0.187 [−0.308, −0.082]). A post-hoc job-level analysis finds the same sign in all five jobs (t interval over jobs [−0.295, −0.089]), but these are only five calibration units on three devices. (b) Added value of the probes over vendor calibration plus circuit metadata was not established: SPS minus a metadata-only predictor was +0.069 [−0.004, +0.143] and +0.010 [−0.088, +0.115] on the two IBM days. (c) SPS was cheaper on some axes: half the circuit configurations, 0.24× the two-qubit gate executions and about 0.74× the QPU time (pro-rated from mixed jobs). (d) The suite-level bound covered IBM (30/30; 86/88 on the fresh day) and IQM (18/18, descriptive), failed on Rigetti (6/30), and was restored by one perdevice calibration (21/21, then 26/26 three days later) at about three times IBM’s width; that US$34.50 calibration is recovered after about 12 screening batches at list prices. An SPS-first cascade gave no QPU saving on hardware. Data, pre-registrations and code are openly released.
Authors
- Asad Ali
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-14
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24210212
- Primary Topic
- Quantum Computing Algorithms and Architecture
- Type
- preprint