Prioritization of Machinery Replacement through Incremental Economic Analysis and FUCOM-TOPSIS in a Furniture Company in Hidalgo
The renewal of machinery in companies with limited financial resources requires distinguishing between the economic convenience of replacing an asset and the relative priority of the available projects. This study analyzes four proposed replacements for Mobilesco con Firmeza, a furniture company located in Hidalgo, Mexico: panel saw, industrial cutoff saw, electrostatic paint booth, and electrostatic paint oven. A quantitative, non-experimental, documentary case study was developed, based on the critical review of the provided file. The procedure reconstructed the defender–challenger cash flows, calculated present value, annual worth, and incremental internal rate of return, and used the weights attributed to FUCOM to perform a TOPSIS ranking. Inconsistencies of transcription, economic thresholds, and sensitivity scenarios were also examined. The corrected results ranked the panel saw in first place, with a closeness coefficient of 0.814232, followed by the cutoff saw, the oven, and the booth. However, the four projects presented negative incremental present values at the recorded evaluation rates. The panel saw would require additional net benefits of 8,072.21 pesos per year to reach financial equilibrium. Its first position was preserved in 21 of 22 individual weight perturbations, but passed to the cutoff saw when the relative weight of capacity was increased by 20%. The hypothesis of priority for the panel saw received conditional support; that of immediate economic viability was not supported. It is concluded that the model allows organizing the review of investments, although it does not by itself justify their execution. Its definitive application requires validating the technical valuations, homologating energy consumption, and documenting the original preferences of the evaluating team.
Authors
- Yohensis Mariam Guillen Zamora
- Erik Rodríguez Soto
- Carlos Darío Acevedo Magaña
- Dariana Anaya González
- Claudia Reyes Bolaños
- Verónica Gómez Arriaga
Institutions
- Tecnológico Nacional de México, Campus Pachuca (MX)
Publication Details
- Journal
- International Journal of Research and Innovation in Social Science
- Published
- 2026-11-14
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.47772/ijriss.2026.102500003
- Primary Topic
- Multi-Criteria Decision Making
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00