A Comparison of Different Models to Compute Cardiac Output by Open-Circuit Inert Gas Wash-In

PURPOSE: Cardiac output (Q̇) can be measured non-invasively during exercise using the open-circuit acetylene (C2H2) uptake method. However, it is unclear whether different calculation techniques for these breathing-based Q̇ measurements yield consistent values and how variations in breathing patterns affect them. This study compared breathing-derived Q̇ estimates from three validated models (Wagner et al.: WAG, Gan et al.: GAN, and Iterative: ITER) and examined the effect of doubling breathing frequency on these estimates during continuous cycling exercise. METHODS: Fourteen healthy adults completed two 28-min constant-work-rate cycling stages at moderate (MOD) and heavy (HVY) intensities. At each stage, Q̇ was measured under normal, self-selected breathing (NF) and under controlled high-frequency breathing (HF) at 200% of NF. For every C2H2 uptake trial, Q̇ was calculated using WAG, GAN, and ITER models. RESULTS: Doubling breathing frequency had model-specific effects on Q̇ estimates. WAG produced significantly lower Q̇ during HF breathing compared with NF at both MOD (3.3±1.1 L·min -1; p<0.001) and HVY (2.8±1.8 L·min -1; p<0.001) intensities. In contrast, ITER yielded significantly higher Q̇ under high-frequency breathing (MOD: -1.7±1.0 L·min -1 and HVY: -3.0±1.6 L·min -1; p<0.001 for both). GAN showed only a small significant difference between breathing conditions at MOD (-0.4±0.7 L·min -1; p=0.039), but not at HVY (p=0.845). CONCLUSIONS: These findings demonstrate that breathing frequency can meaningfully influence C2H2-derived Q̇ estimates and that computational models differ markedly in their sensitivity to ventilatory pattern. GAN appears to be the most robust to altered breathing frequency compared to WAG and ITER. Consistency in model selection is essential when using inert-gas uptake techniques to assess Q̇ during exercise.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise
Published
2026-11-13
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1249/mss.0000000000004209
Primary Topic
Cardiovascular and exercise physiology
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

A Comparison of Different Models to Compute Cardiac Output by Open-Circuit Inert Gas Wash-In

Daniel A. Keir, Robin Faricier, Daniel W. Gregory
Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise
Cardiovascular and exercise physiology
article

A Comparison of Different Models to Compute Cardiac Output by Open-Circuit Inert Gas Wash-In

Daniel A. Keir, Robin Faricier, Daniel W. Gregory
article en

Abstract

PURPOSE: Cardiac output (Q̇) can be measured non-invasively during exercise using the open-circuit acetylene (C2H2) uptake method. However, it is unclear whether different calculation techniques for these breathing-based Q̇ measurements yield consistent values and how variations in breathing patterns affect them. This study compared breathing-derived Q̇ estimates from three validated models (Wagner et al.: WAG, Gan et al.: GAN, and Iterative: ITER) and examined the effect of doubling breathing frequency on these estimates during continuous cycling exercise. METHODS: Fourteen healthy adults completed two 28-min constant-work-rate cycling stages at moderate (MOD) and heavy (HVY) intensities. At each stage, Q̇ was measured under normal, self-selected breathing (NF) and under controlled high-frequency breathing (HF) at 200% of NF. For every C2H2 uptake trial, Q̇ was calculated using WAG, GAN, and ITER models. RESULTS: Doubling breathing frequency had model-specific effects on Q̇ estimates. WAG produced significantly lower Q̇ during HF breathing compared with NF at both MOD (3.3±1.1 L·min -1; p<0.001) and HVY (2.8±1.8 L·min -1; p<0.001) intensities. In contrast, ITER yielded significantly higher Q̇ under high-frequency breathing (MOD: -1.7±1.0 L·min -1 and HVY: -3.0±1.6 L·min -1; p<0.001 for both). GAN showed only a small significant difference between breathing conditions at MOD (-0.4±0.7 L·min -1; p=0.039), but not at HVY (p=0.845). CONCLUSIONS: These findings demonstrate that breathing frequency can meaningfully influence C2H2-derived Q̇ estimates and that computational models differ markedly in their sensitivity to ventilatory pattern. GAN appears to be the most robust to altered breathing frequency compared to WAG and ITER. Consistency in model selection is essential when using inert-gas uptake techniques to assess Q̇ during exercise.

Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise
Western University (CA), Lawson Health Research Institute (CA), Toronto General Hospital (CA), Toronto General Hospital Research Institute (CA)
Good health and well-being
Cardiovascular and exercise physiology
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon