Exploring the Integration of Emerging Technologies in Skills-Based TVET Curricula in Secondary Schools: A Critical Review

Technical and vocational education and training at secondary level is under sustained pressure to incorporate artificial intelligence, immersive simulation, automation, robotics and related digital technologies into curricula organised around occupational skills. Policy discourse often treats such integration as self-evidently beneficial, yet the empirical basis for this assumption has not been critically consolidated for the secondary phase, where learners are younger, provision is largely school-based and resource constraints are acute. This critical narrative review examines how emerging technologies are being integrated into skills-based secondary vocational curricula, what the evidence shows about their effects on learning and transition outcomes, and which conditions shape implementation. Peer-reviewed studies and institutional reports published from 2011 onwards were identified through education-specific and multidisciplinary scholarly indexes, citation tracking and searches of intergovernmental sources, and were appraised for design adequacy, contextual relevance and outcome validity. The synthesis indicates that curricula are changing more slowly and more unevenly than forecasts of automation imply, and that curriculum documents tend to emphasise tool use over broader digital and occupational competence. Immersive and simulation-based technologies show the most consistent short-term benefits for cognitive and procedural outcomes, although these benefits shrink or disappear when comparison conditions are equally well designed, and greater realism or presence does not reliably translate into better learning. Evidence on learning factories, artificial intelligence and generative tools in secondary vocational settings remains largely descriptive, perception-based or developmental. Teacher digital competence, institutional support, infrastructure and links with workplaces appear to shape integration more strongly than the technologies themselves, while patterns by gender, disability, location and income suggest that technology-rich provision can reproduce rather than reduce inequality. Major unresolved questions concern transfer to authentic work, long-term labour-market returns, the balance between general and occupation-specific skills, and the governance of data-driven tools. The review proposes an integrative framework that separates supported from hypothesised relationships and argues that integration should be judged by its contribution to durable vocational competence rather than by technological novelty.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Asian Journal of Education and Social Studies
Published
2026-11-13
DOI
https://doi.org/10.9734/ajess/2026/v52i113478
Primary Topic
Vocational Education and Training
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Exploring the Integration of Emerging Technologies in Skills-Based TVET Curricula in Secondary Schools: A Critical Review

Ezrone Robert Mkandawire, Bako Abdalla Hama Salih, Doris Wangui Muturi, Richeno Alberto Matimbe
1 links
Asian Journal of Education and Social Studies
Vocational Education and Training
article

Exploring the Integration of Emerging Technologies in Skills-Based TVET Curricula in Secondary Schools: A Critical Review

Ezrone Robert Mkandawire, Bako Abdalla Hama Salih, Doris Wangui Muturi, Richeno Alberto Matimbe
article en

Abstract

Technical and vocational education and training at secondary level is under sustained pressure to incorporate artificial intelligence, immersive simulation, automation, robotics and related digital technologies into curricula organised around occupational skills. Policy discourse often treats such integration as self-evidently beneficial, yet the empirical basis for this assumption has not been critically consolidated for the secondary phase, where learners are younger, provision is largely school-based and resource constraints are acute. This critical narrative review examines how emerging technologies are being integrated into skills-based secondary vocational curricula, what the evidence shows about their effects on learning and transition outcomes, and which conditions shape implementation. Peer-reviewed studies and institutional reports published from 2011 onwards were identified through education-specific and multidisciplinary scholarly indexes, citation tracking and searches of intergovernmental sources, and were appraised for design adequacy, contextual relevance and outcome validity. The synthesis indicates that curricula are changing more slowly and more unevenly than forecasts of automation imply, and that curriculum documents tend to emphasise tool use over broader digital and occupational competence. Immersive and simulation-based technologies show the most consistent short-term benefits for cognitive and procedural outcomes, although these benefits shrink or disappear when comparison conditions are equally well designed, and greater realism or presence does not reliably translate into better learning. Evidence on learning factories, artificial intelligence and generative tools in secondary vocational settings remains largely descriptive, perception-based or developmental. Teacher digital competence, institutional support, infrastructure and links with workplaces appear to shape integration more strongly than the technologies themselves, while patterns by gender, disability, location and income suggest that technology-rich provision can reproduce rather than reduce inequality. Major unresolved questions concern transfer to authentic work, long-term labour-market returns, the balance between general and occupation-specific skills, and the governance of data-driven tools. The review proposes an integrative framework that separates supported from hypothesised relationships and argues that integration should be judged by its contribution to durable vocational competence rather than by technological novelty.

Asian Journal of Education and Social StudiesVol. 52(11)
Zhejiang Normal University (CN)
Quality education, Industry, innovation and infrastructure
Vocational Education and Training
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon