The Insight Engine: A Research Programme for Verifiable Structural Transfer in Human–AI Engineering Problem Solving
The Insight Engine research programme asks whether a machine can identify useful changes to the representation and boundary conditions of an engineering problem, rather than only optimise solutions within the problem as first formulated. The question arose from first-person reflection on engineering practice — episodes in which an apparently necessary constraint dissolved once a different causal relationship was recognised, or an existing physical property was used in another way. This phenomenological origin motivates, but does not validate, a computational hypothesis. We propose a human–AI architecture built on explicit physical entities, relationships, uncertainty, candidate transformations, structurally retrieved analogies, and independently evaluated physical consequences. Its central methodological commitment is the distinction between an explanation offered after a solution and an auditable sequence in which a donor structure and its mapping are recorded before they generate a candidate, then tested by intervention rather than accepted because the answer happens to be correct. We report what the prototype has and has not shown. Internal tests give restricted evidence of useful cross-domain transfer under supplied reduced-physics models; an external holdout was halted at preflight when it revealed coverage limits beyond the prototype’s capability, rather than scored misleadingly. The programme is positioned against structure-mapping, analogical retrieval, qualitative physics, program-library learning, and recent mechanism-centric cross-domain retrieval. The contribution is therefore a well-posed research problem, a proposed integration of existing methods, and a falsifiable evaluation protocol with pre-registered criteria — not a claim to have produced machine insight.
Authors
- Mark Cragg (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0006-2161-736X)
Publication Details
- Published
- 2026-11-13
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.33774/coe-2026-hh0k1
- Primary Topic
- AI-based Problem Solving and Planning
- Type
- preprint