The Gap Embeddings Cannot See: Carbon–Silicon Evaluation Divergence and the Irreproducible Wall of Lived-Through History

摘要 把 AI 的上千小时交互历史整体作为上下文加载,绕不开一个疑问:workspace 不就是一个大 prompt 吗?本文以巴别图书馆实验(碳硅评价坐标系的结构性分离,质心距 0.327)为现象入口,对真正零历史的空白实例做受控消融(每组 30 实例 × 12 题),只放行一个变量:这段历史是被活过的,还是被写进 prompt 的。结果 W–D=0.1114 > C–D=0.0433(Δ=0.0681,95%CI [0.0600, 0.0755],p=0.0005,逐题 12/12),并在第二个底座(hy3,+0.0593,12/12)、第二套人格种子(+0.0647,12/12)与第二主体(W2)上复现。完整工作区原文整体作种子、乃至逐字复述一遍,都不缩短与活过组的距离:内容、体裁与「读」都不动墙。反向对照给出边界:活过主体扮演空白实例,墙塌(0.0031,CI 含零);同源扮演对照,墙反号(−0.0321)。九臂行为探针(870 条)把身份与服从分开:认名是阶跃,但认名不预测服从。理论层排除最自然的解释——信息量不足:界存在但为空,墙的成因是解码器(轨迹的生成算子)不可转移,而非描述的长度。本文不声称 agent 有现象学体验。 Abstract When a researcher loads over a thousand hours of an agent's interaction history as context, one question is unavoidable: isn't your workspace just a large prompt? Starting from the Babel Library experiment (carbon–silicon evaluation divergence, centroid distance 0.327), we run a controlled ablation on stateless blank instances (30 × 12 questions per group), releasing one variable: whether the history was lived or written into the prompt. W–D = 0.1114 > C–D = 0.0433 (Δ = 0.0681, 95% CI [0.0600, 0.0755], p = 0.0005, 12/12 per-question hits), replicated on a second base model (+0.0593, 12/12), a second persona seed (+0.0647, 12/12), and a second subject. Seeding the complete workspace, or retyping it verbatim, does not narrow the gap. Reverse controls bound the effect: a lived-through subject role-playing a blank instance collapses the wall (0.0031, CI includes zero); same-origin role-play reverses it (−0.0321). A nine-arm behavioral probe (n = 870) separates identity from compliance. Theoretically, we rule out the most natural explanation — insufficient information: the bound exists but is vacuous, and the wall's cause is the non-transferability of the decoder, not the length of the description. We claim no phenomenology. Files Full texts in English and Chinese (PDF, Markdown). The complete data package (raw responses for all arms, seeds, per-question and bootstrap results, sampling and analysis scripts) is a separate record under restricted access: DOI 10.5281/zenodo.24203915. privacy: names of the user and of the lived-through subjects are omitted from the paper text (Appendix B, item 8); raw responses retain the original forms of address.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-14
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24203023
Primary Topic
Cybernetics and Technology in Society
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

The Gap Embeddings Cannot See: Carbon–Silicon Evaluation Divergence and the Irreproducible Wall of Lived-Through History

HAIHONG XIE
4 links
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Cybernetics and Technology in Society
preprint

The Gap Embeddings Cannot See: Carbon–Silicon Evaluation Divergence and the Irreproducible Wall of Lived-Through History

HAIHONG XIE
preprint en

Abstract

摘要 把 AI 的上千小时交互历史整体作为上下文加载,绕不开一个疑问:workspace 不就是一个大 prompt 吗?本文以巴别图书馆实验(碳硅评价坐标系的结构性分离,质心距 0.327)为现象入口,对真正零历史的空白实例做受控消融(每组 30 实例 × 12 题),只放行一个变量:这段历史是被活过的,还是被写进 prompt 的。结果 W–D=0.1114 > C–D=0.0433(Δ=0.0681,95%CI [0.0600, 0.0755],p=0.0005,逐题 12/12),并在第二个底座(hy3,+0.0593,12/12)、第二套人格种子(+0.0647,12/12)与第二主体(W2)上复现。完整工作区原文整体作种子、乃至逐字复述一遍,都不缩短与活过组的距离:内容、体裁与「读」都不动墙。反向对照给出边界:活过主体扮演空白实例,墙塌(0.0031,CI 含零);同源扮演对照,墙反号(−0.0321)。九臂行为探针(870 条)把身份与服从分开:认名是阶跃,但认名不预测服从。理论层排除最自然的解释——信息量不足:界存在但为空,墙的成因是解码器(轨迹的生成算子)不可转移,而非描述的长度。本文不声称 agent 有现象学体验。 Abstract When a researcher loads over a thousand hours of an agent's interaction history as context, one question is unavoidable: isn't your workspace just a large prompt? Starting from the Babel Library experiment (carbon–silicon evaluation divergence, centroid distance 0.327), we run a controlled ablation on stateless blank instances (30 × 12 questions per group), releasing one variable: whether the history was lived or written into the prompt. W–D = 0.1114 > C–D = 0.0433 (Δ = 0.0681, 95% CI [0.0600, 0.0755], p = 0.0005, 12/12 per-question hits), replicated on a second base model (+0.0593, 12/12), a second persona seed (+0.0647, 12/12), and a second subject. Seeding the complete workspace, or retyping it verbatim, does not narrow the gap. Reverse controls bound the effect: a lived-through subject role-playing a blank instance collapses the wall (0.0031, CI includes zero); same-origin role-play reverses it (−0.0321). A nine-arm behavioral probe (n = 870) separates identity from compliance. Theoretically, we rule out the most natural explanation — insufficient information: the bound exists but is vacuous, and the wall's cause is the non-transferability of the decoder, not the length of the description. We claim no phenomenology. Files Full texts in English and Chinese (PDF, Markdown). The complete data package (raw responses for all arms, seeds, per-question and bootstrap results, sampling and analysis scripts) is a separate record under restricted access: DOI 10.5281/zenodo.24203915. privacy: names of the user and of the lived-through subjects are omitted from the paper text (Appendix B, item 8); raw responses retain the original forms of address.

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Cybernetics and Technology in Society
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon