Engineering Education Research and Skills for Future Development: A Comparative Modelling Study of Curriculum Configurations Under Varying Institutional Capacity

Engineering graduates are entering a workplace where knowing the technical fundamentals is no longer enough. Employers increasingly look for graduates who can solve unfamiliar problems, make sound design decisions, work confidently with digital tools, communicate clearly, and continue learning without constant supervision. This paper describes a controlled modelling study that compares four curriculum approaches: a lecture-centred baseline, active learning augmentation, project-based learning organised around CDIO principles, and industry-integrated project-based learning. All four are assessed using the same seven-domain competency framework, developed from accreditation criteria and published evidence on employer skill needs. To keep the comparison fair, the same simulated learner cohort is passed through every approach rather than generating a different cohort for each one. Three hundred cohorts are simulated under each of three institutional capacity conditions: well-resourced, moderately-resourced, and constrained. The study reports a composite competency attainment index, the percentage of the employer-referenced gap that is closed, a simulated delivery-cost index, ninety-five percent confidence intervals, and matched non-parametric statistical tests. Under well-resourced settings, the model gives mean attainment values of 60.11 for the baseline, 62.81 for active learning augmentation, 64.85 for project-based learning, and 65.97 for industry-integrated project-based learning, with Kendall's W = 0.429 and p < 0.001 in the Friedman test. As institutional resources become constrained, however, this ordering becomes less distinct. In the constrained scenario, the advantage of industry-integrated delivery falls to 2.70 index points, and the difference from project-based learning is no longer statistically separable after Holm adjustment at the 0.05 level. Active learning augmentation also retains much of its benefit while requiring considerably less simulated cost. The sensitivity analysis places the crossover between industry-integrated and project-based learning at about eighty-five students per staff member. Beyond that point, the most resource-intensive approach no longer produces the highest simulated attainment. These numbers come from a model input-based simulation, not from observations of an actual programme or student cohort. The aim is therefore to make the underlying reasoning transparent and repeatable, and to show when the additional effort required by high-contact teaching is supported by the model.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Iconic Research and Engineering Journals
Published
2026-11-13
DOI
https://doi.org/10.64388/ire1724916
Primary Topic
Engineering Education and Curriculum Development
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Engineering Education Research and Skills for Future Development: A Comparative Modelling Study of Curriculum Configurations Under Varying Institutional Capacity

Tushar Sehrawat, shrashti jaiswal, Navneet Kumar, Palak Jain
Iconic Research and Engineering Journals
Engineering Education and Curriculum Development
article

Engineering Education Research and Skills for Future Development: A Comparative Modelling Study of Curriculum Configurations Under Varying Institutional Capacity

Tushar Sehrawat, shrashti jaiswal, Navneet Kumar, Palak Jain
article en

Abstract

Engineering graduates are entering a workplace where knowing the technical fundamentals is no longer enough. Employers increasingly look for graduates who can solve unfamiliar problems, make sound design decisions, work confidently with digital tools, communicate clearly, and continue learning without constant supervision. This paper describes a controlled modelling study that compares four curriculum approaches: a lecture-centred baseline, active learning augmentation, project-based learning organised around CDIO principles, and industry-integrated project-based learning. All four are assessed using the same seven-domain competency framework, developed from accreditation criteria and published evidence on employer skill needs. To keep the comparison fair, the same simulated learner cohort is passed through every approach rather than generating a different cohort for each one. Three hundred cohorts are simulated under each of three institutional capacity conditions: well-resourced, moderately-resourced, and constrained. The study reports a composite competency attainment index, the percentage of the employer-referenced gap that is closed, a simulated delivery-cost index, ninety-five percent confidence intervals, and matched non-parametric statistical tests. Under well-resourced settings, the model gives mean attainment values of 60.11 for the baseline, 62.81 for active learning augmentation, 64.85 for project-based learning, and 65.97 for industry-integrated project-based learning, with Kendall's W = 0.429 and p < 0.001 in the Friedman test. As institutional resources become constrained, however, this ordering becomes less distinct. In the constrained scenario, the advantage of industry-integrated delivery falls to 2.70 index points, and the difference from project-based learning is no longer statistically separable after Holm adjustment at the 0.05 level. Active learning augmentation also retains much of its benefit while requiring considerably less simulated cost. The sensitivity analysis places the crossover between industry-integrated and project-based learning at about eighty-five students per staff member. Beyond that point, the most resource-intensive approach no longer produces the highest simulated attainment. These numbers come from a model input-based simulation, not from observations of an actual programme or student cohort. The aim is therefore to make the underlying reasoning transparent and repeatable, and to show when the additional effort required by high-contact teaching is supported by the model.

Iconic Research and Engineering JournalsVol. 10(5)
Bharati Vidyapeeth (Deemed to be University) (IN)
Quality education, Decent work and economic growth
Engineering Education and Curriculum Development
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon