The Recognition Trap in Papua: Ethnic Inequality and the Politics of Multicultural Governance

Abstract The expansion of multicultural governance has increasingly been regarded as a pathway for addressing historical injustice and strengthening the political inclusion of Indigenous peoples, yet persistent ethnic inequality across many postcolonial societies raises important questions about the transformative capacity of recognition itself. Papua, Indonesia, represents a particularly revealing case where the implementation of Special Autonomy, affirmative policies, and broader institutional recognition of Indigenous Papuans ( Orang Asli Papua /OAP) has progressed alongside enduring disparities in political authority, bureaucratic influence, and access to strategic state resources. Drawing on critical ethnographic research conducted in Jayapura through participant observation, in-depth interviews, and documentary analysis, this article examines how recognition operates within the everyday practices of multicultural governance. Rather than treating recognition as a normative achievement or merely an incomplete policy agenda, the analysis reveals that it has become embedded within bureaucratic procedures, administrative classifications, and institutional arrangements that formally acknowledge Indigenous identity while simultaneously preserving unequal relations of power. These empirical dynamics provide the basis for developing the concept of the Recognition Trap, which explains how recognition may function as an institutional mechanism that expands symbolic inclusion while reproducing structural inequality through the governance of ethnic identity. By positioning Papua as a theory-generating case rather than a peripheral illustration of existing theories, the article offers a broader conceptual contribution to debates on nationalism, ethnic politics, and multicultural governance, arguing that meaningful recognition requires not only legal and cultural affirmation but also the transformation of institutional structures through which political authority, citizenship, and public resources are organized.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Research Square
Published
2026-11-13
DOI
https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11368847/v1
Primary Topic
Asian Studies and History
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

The Recognition Trap in Papua: Ethnic Inequality and the Politics of Multicultural Governance

Simon Abdi K. Frank, Vinsensio H.A. Dugis, Usman Idris, Toetik Koerbardiati
3 links
Research Square
Asian Studies and History
preprint

The Recognition Trap in Papua: Ethnic Inequality and the Politics of Multicultural Governance

Simon Abdi K. Frank, Vinsensio H.A. Dugis, Usman Idris, Toetik Koerbardiati
preprint en

Abstract

Abstract The expansion of multicultural governance has increasingly been regarded as a pathway for addressing historical injustice and strengthening the political inclusion of Indigenous peoples, yet persistent ethnic inequality across many postcolonial societies raises important questions about the transformative capacity of recognition itself. Papua, Indonesia, represents a particularly revealing case where the implementation of Special Autonomy, affirmative policies, and broader institutional recognition of Indigenous Papuans ( Orang Asli Papua /OAP) has progressed alongside enduring disparities in political authority, bureaucratic influence, and access to strategic state resources. Drawing on critical ethnographic research conducted in Jayapura through participant observation, in-depth interviews, and documentary analysis, this article examines how recognition operates within the everyday practices of multicultural governance. Rather than treating recognition as a normative achievement or merely an incomplete policy agenda, the analysis reveals that it has become embedded within bureaucratic procedures, administrative classifications, and institutional arrangements that formally acknowledge Indigenous identity while simultaneously preserving unequal relations of power. These empirical dynamics provide the basis for developing the concept of the Recognition Trap, which explains how recognition may function as an institutional mechanism that expands symbolic inclusion while reproducing structural inequality through the governance of ethnic identity. By positioning Papua as a theory-generating case rather than a peripheral illustration of existing theories, the article offers a broader conceptual contribution to debates on nationalism, ethnic politics, and multicultural governance, arguing that meaningful recognition requires not only legal and cultural affirmation but also the transformation of institutional structures through which political authority, citizenship, and public resources are organized.

Research Square
Universitas Airlangga (ID), Cenderawasih University (ID)
Peace, justice, and strong institutions, Reduced inequalities
Asian Studies and History
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon