The Most Cited Papers Are Not the Best Starting Points: What the Reception of a Paper's Citing Papers Tells an Author

Manuscript, state of 13 November 2026. The file is restricted; this record documents the state of the text at this date. Abstract. Which papers of an established field are good starting points for new work? Papers that build on the most cited papers are received hardly better than average. We test a rule that follows from Newman's hope that papers standing out against their contemporaries do so by their quality: rank papers by the mean cohort z-score of the papers that cite them. In two fields of arXiv, artificial intelligence and mathematics, 12.6% and 8.7% of the papers that newly cite a recent paper become strongly received. For the top 2% by our rule the shares are 20.6% and 16.5%; by Newman's z-score 13.8% and 10.9%; by time-rescaled PageRank 12.6% and 8.8%. Against controls of the same category, citation count and age the ratio is 1.47 and 1.48; it is 1.34 and 1.30 when the citing authors have the same record of earlier reception, and 1.12 in artificial intelligence within the same author. The evidence is observational, and the rule does not predict how often the paper itself is cited. All 70 predictions were sealed and their checksums deposited before each measurement; thirteen failed. The rule specified in advance as primary held but adds nothing detectable to the simpler rule. The checksums of the sealed analysis plans and of the programs are deposited separately: doi:10.5281/zenodo.24138400 (all versions).

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-13
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24201592
Primary Topic
scientometrics and bibliometrics research
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

The Most Cited Papers Are Not the Best Starting Points: What the Reception of a Paper's Citing Papers Tells an Author

Philipp von Hilgers
1 links
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
scientometrics and bibliometrics research
preprint

The Most Cited Papers Are Not the Best Starting Points: What the Reception of a Paper's Citing Papers Tells an Author

Philipp von Hilgers
preprint en

Abstract

Manuscript, state of 13 November 2026. The file is restricted; this record documents the state of the text at this date. Abstract. Which papers of an established field are good starting points for new work? Papers that build on the most cited papers are received hardly better than average. We test a rule that follows from Newman's hope that papers standing out against their contemporaries do so by their quality: rank papers by the mean cohort z-score of the papers that cite them. In two fields of arXiv, artificial intelligence and mathematics, 12.6% and 8.7% of the papers that newly cite a recent paper become strongly received. For the top 2% by our rule the shares are 20.6% and 16.5%; by Newman's z-score 13.8% and 10.9%; by time-rescaled PageRank 12.6% and 8.8%. Against controls of the same category, citation count and age the ratio is 1.47 and 1.48; it is 1.34 and 1.30 when the citing authors have the same record of earlier reception, and 1.12 in artificial intelligence within the same author. The evidence is observational, and the rule does not predict how often the paper itself is cited. All 70 predictions were sealed and their checksums deposited before each measurement; thirteen failed. The rule specified in advance as primary held but adds nothing detectable to the simpler rule. The checksums of the sealed analysis plans and of the programs are deposited separately: doi:10.5281/zenodo.24138400 (all versions).

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
scientometrics and bibliometrics research
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon