Scale preservation is not enough: a profile-level independence countermodel for the Corollary 3.12 assembly inputs
We exhibit a concrete profile-valued countermodel showing that the remaining value-group profile switch in a conditional assembly from Theorem 3.11 to Corollary 3.12 in inter-universal Teichmuller theory is logically independent of the other assembly inputs. At l=7, with labels j=1,2,3 at one bad place and normalized unit u=1, the theta-side readouts are -j^2 and the q-side readouts are -1, with equal procession weights 1/3. The normalized generator and unit-side readouts agree, membership, monotonicity, hull domain and both volume decompositions hold, but the aggregates are -14/3 and -1, the aggregate scale is forced to 3/14, and the Corollary-3.12-shaped conclusion fails. For general odd primes l>=5 the aggregate scale is 12/(l(l+1)). The countermodel and independence corollary are formalized in Lean 4; the recorded selected build passes with only the standard three axioms. The profile and normalizations are the source readouts (theta values q^{j^2}, plain procession averaging, and the coefficient comparison in IUT IV Theorem 1.10), not arbitrary choices. This note does not claim that Mochizuki's actual construction is this model, nor that Theorem 3.11, Corollary 3.12, the ABC conjecture or H*val is false. It proves only that no derivation exists from the listed inputs once labelwise profile equality is removed; further progress requires a genuinely profile-level input or a richer formalization of the actual construction. Version 1.0.1 adds a remark that the countermodel keeps the membership hypothesis hmem and removes only the labelwise profile equality hlocal, relating it to the pair hmem and hlocal that is the Lean counterpart of H*val in the assembly note from its version 1.0.2; it also rewords the description of the Lean build and rewrites the comments of the supplementary Lean files in English. No theorem or conclusion is changed.
Authors
- Toshihisa Urahigashi (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0004-0460-6242)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-13
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24195283
- Primary Topic
- Algebraic Geometry and Number Theory
- Type
- preprint