Cryptographic Transition Studies: A Field and a Research Agenda
Every digital system rests on cryptography, and every cryptographic foundation is eventually replaced. The present replacement, the migration to post-quantum cryptography, is treated across the literature as an engineering task: an inventory to build, an algorithm to swap, a deadline to meet. Senior cryptographers have asked, in this field's most prominent venues, where the research on cryptographic transition and agility actually is. The answer is that the research has no field to belong to. This Perspective names one. Cryptographic transition studies is the interdisciplinary study of how societies replace the cryptography they depend on, taking the transition, rather than the algorithm, as its object. The transition recurs across the history of secret-keeping, from the retirement of the Data Encryption Standard to the collapse of SHA-1, and each instance shares a structure that no single discipline is organized to study. I advance two conjectures about that structure, the decision rule they force, and an agenda built on them: the concealment asymmetry, that an adversary able to exploit a break against long-lived secrets conceals it rather than announcing it, so a transition cannot be timed from observable events; the build-rate ceiling, that a transition runs past its deadline because an installed base is replaced no faster than the slowest part of it can be found and reached; and, forced by both, the secrecy horizon, the rule that a transition must begin before it can be proven necessary, keyed to the shelf-life of what must stay secret. I map the field across ten sub-disciplines and set a research agenda whose ambition is to make the replacement of a society's cryptography something that can be forecast, measured, and defended against, instead of improvised. The post-quantum migration is the field's founding instance, not its subject. A society that improvises each transition pays the improvisation cost every time.
Authors
- Addie LaMarr (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0003-8832-5204)
Institutions
- Lamarr Institute for Machine Learning and Artificial Intelligence (DE)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-13
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24206702
- Primary Topic
- Cryptography and Data Security
- Type
- preprint