Applied versus faced trade protectionism and ecological sustainability: Evidence from a dynamic panel threshold and quantile regression analysis of 96 countries

The question of the environmental consequences of protectionism has emerged as an urgent issue at the intersection of international political economy and sustainability studies, as the world economy becomes increasingly fragmented into competing trade blocs. The environmental cost of trade protectionism is often seen in the barriers a country puts up, but the barriers it faces from other countries may be more significant. What matters is which of the two determines where the ecological burden of a fragmenting trading system falls and which governments are in a position to act on it. This study disentangles applied protection (i.e., the restrictiveness of a country's own trade policy) and faced protection (i.e., the intensity with which a country is targeted by anti-dumping measures abroad) and tests their effects on ecological sustainability. Using a balanced panel of 96 countries over the period 2001-2022, environmental sustainability is measured by the load capacity factor (the ratio of biocapacity to ecological footprint), a supply-inclusive measure that goes beyond carbon emissions alone. We test the load capacity curve using static and dynamic panel threshold models, modelling faced protection as a targeting regime, employing second-generation methods robust to cross-sectional dependence, including the CIPS unit-root test, Westerlund cointegration, Driscoll–Kraay standard errors, and method-of-moments quantile regression. The results show a strong asymmetry. Applied protection has no detectable threshold effect on the load capacity factor, a result obtained with two independent measures. The load capacity factor declines monotonically with income over the income range spanned by the panel, so the recovery arm posited by the load capacity curve hypothesis is not detected in this global sample. Protection, by contrast, conditions the relationship: in heavily targeted countries the adverse association between growth and ecological sustainability is about twice as large as in never-targeted countries, a difference robust across the conditional distribution. Because targeting is not randomly assigned, this contrast is interpreted as a strong conditional association, not a fully identified causal effect. Importantly, this pattern works mainly through the biological ecological footprint (cropland, grazing land, forest, and fishing grounds) and not through carbon: decomposing the footprint reveals a regime gap several times larger in its biological than in its carbon component and none at all in aggregate carbon emissions, a channel largely missed by carbon-only analyses. Our results indicate that the ecological costs of trade fragmentation are borne by the countries targeted and that trade policy assessments—in economics, environmental governance, and development policy—need to look beyond carbon.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Social Sciences & Humanities Open
Published
2026-11-13
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ssaho.2026.104046
Primary Topic
Energy, Environment, Economic Growth
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Applied versus faced trade protectionism and ecological sustainability: Evidence from a dynamic panel threshold and quantile regression analysis of 96 countries

Ahsen Emir Bulut, Turan Karımlı
Social Sciences & Humanities Open
Energy, Environment, Economic Growth
article

Applied versus faced trade protectionism and ecological sustainability: Evidence from a dynamic panel threshold and quantile regression analysis of 96 countries

Ahsen Emir Bulut, Turan Karımlı
article en

Abstract

The question of the environmental consequences of protectionism has emerged as an urgent issue at the intersection of international political economy and sustainability studies, as the world economy becomes increasingly fragmented into competing trade blocs. The environmental cost of trade protectionism is often seen in the barriers a country puts up, but the barriers it faces from other countries may be more significant. What matters is which of the two determines where the ecological burden of a fragmenting trading system falls and which governments are in a position to act on it. This study disentangles applied protection (i.e., the restrictiveness of a country's own trade policy) and faced protection (i.e., the intensity with which a country is targeted by anti-dumping measures abroad) and tests their effects on ecological sustainability. Using a balanced panel of 96 countries over the period 2001-2022, environmental sustainability is measured by the load capacity factor (the ratio of biocapacity to ecological footprint), a supply-inclusive measure that goes beyond carbon emissions alone. We test the load capacity curve using static and dynamic panel threshold models, modelling faced protection as a targeting regime, employing second-generation methods robust to cross-sectional dependence, including the CIPS unit-root test, Westerlund cointegration, Driscoll–Kraay standard errors, and method-of-moments quantile regression. The results show a strong asymmetry. Applied protection has no detectable threshold effect on the load capacity factor, a result obtained with two independent measures. The load capacity factor declines monotonically with income over the income range spanned by the panel, so the recovery arm posited by the load capacity curve hypothesis is not detected in this global sample. Protection, by contrast, conditions the relationship: in heavily targeted countries the adverse association between growth and ecological sustainability is about twice as large as in never-targeted countries, a difference robust across the conditional distribution. Because targeting is not randomly assigned, this contrast is interpreted as a strong conditional association, not a fully identified causal effect. Importantly, this pattern works mainly through the biological ecological footprint (cropland, grazing land, forest, and fishing grounds) and not through carbon: decomposing the footprint reveals a regime gap several times larger in its biological than in its carbon component and none at all in aggregate carbon emissions, a channel largely missed by carbon-only analyses. Our results indicate that the ecological costs of trade fragmentation are borne by the countries targeted and that trade policy assessments—in economics, environmental governance, and development policy—need to look beyond carbon.

Social Sciences & Humanities OpenVol. 14
Dokuz Eylül University (TR), Azerbaijan State University of Economics (AZ)
Energy, Environment, Economic Growth
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon