Where the tonnes go missing: a ledger of delivered versus design CO2 at commercial capture facilities
Carbon capture and storage (CCS) is planned and counted by design capacity. The gap between design and delivery is known; where it opens is not. Earlier studies compared stated capacity with storage and named causes without sizing them. Of 38 commercial facilities in a fixed published population, 16 publish enough to compare reported with design CO2; this paper rebuilds their output from operator and regulator records and enters each shortfall against design in an evidence-coded tonne ledger. Their designs implied 181 Mt and they reported 126 Mt, a mixed-endpoint ratio of 0.69; the 11 that report injected or stored CO2 delivered 0.66. Of the 55.2 Mt shortfall, 35% can be assigned to one stage; 21% is quantified but not assigned, and 44% has no quantified cause. Most assigned tonnes were lost at the sink, as CO2 that Gorgon separated but could not inject and capacity Great Plains could supply beyond the contracts its plans name, and most of the rest at the source. Capture plants were assigned 0.9 Mt, but the record cannot rule out up to 8.5 Mt. Counting Gorgon from the year its field began supplying the plant would add 12.4 Mt to the shortfall, 8.4 Mt of it vented while its compression trains were rebuilt. The results describe the documented cohort only. A one-page annual return, filled in for Petra Nova, Gorgon and Snøhvit, shows that most of what operators would need to report already exists.
Authors
- Milan Perazich
- Milan Savo Perazich (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0005-4480-5315)
Publication Details
- Published
- 2026-11-13
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.22541/essoar.15012142/v1
- Primary Topic
- CO2 Sequestration and Geologic Interactions
- Type
- preprint