The Mass of the Charge: From Stoney's Unit to Bopp's Mass of the charge and the Gravitational Self-Energy of a Point Charge

An essay in the making (a preliminary draft is available on demand) The Mass of the Charge From Stoney’s Unit to Bopp’s Masse der Ladung and the Gravitational Self-Energy of a Point Charge Abstract A remarkable mass scale, (MBL= ec/√G ≈ 1.85921 × 10-6) g in CGS–Gaussian units, appears independently in several developments spanning nearly a century and a half of physics. First introduced by George Johnstone Stoney in 1881 as the mass unit of a natural system of units, the same quantity subsequently acquired distinct physical interpretations in Anton Bopp's unpublished manuscripts (1941–1957), in classical general relativity, and in contemporary discussions of quantum gravity. The paper examines four interpretations of this common mass scale: Stoney's natural unit; Bopp's Masse der Ladung(mass of the charge); the gravitationally dressed self-energy of an electrically charged point particle; and the extremal charge-to-mass threshold appearing in Einstein–Maxwell theory and the Weak Gravity Conjecture. Bopp's contribution is of particular historical and conceptual interest. Beginning in 1941, he distinguished the gravitational rest mass of the electron from a mass associated with its electric charge. By 1943, this distinction had become part of his proposed closure condition connecting electromagnetism, gravitation, and the electron's kinetic zero-point energy. In 1957, he explicitly defined the Masse der Ladung through the equality of Newtonian gravitational attraction and Coulomb repulsion. In Bopp's framework, the ratio between the mass of the charge and the electron mass is expressed through the dimensionless electron–gravity coupling, αeG = ec / (me √G) ≈ 2.04098 × 1021 and related to a characteristic zero-point velocity (v_\omega\approx0.66359) cm/s and frequency (νzp ≈ 0.0605390) Hz. These relations form part of the proposed dimensionless closure condition linking the electron's rest energy to its zero-point energy. A striking parallel appears in the 1960 work of Arnowitt, Deser, and Misner, who showed that including gravitational self-energy yields a finite total mass for a classical point charge, equal to (ec / (me √G) and independent of its bare mechanical mass. Related equilibrium and extremality conditions arise in the Majumdar–Papapetrou and Reissner–Nordström solutions, while the Weak Gravity Conjecture introduces the same scale as a charge-to-mass threshold. Although these formulations converge on an identical numerical quantity, they do not establish identical physical interpretations. In particular, none independently determines the observed electron mass, which is smaller than the mass of its charge by approximately twenty-one orders of magnitude. The central question is therefore not the numerical identity itself, which follows algebraically from the constants, but the physical condition that could determine this enormous separation of scales. Bopp's closure offers a candidate relation, whose significance would become experimentally testable only through an independently identifiable zero-point frequency, velocity, or associated observable. By bringing these historically separate developments together, the paper highlights an unusual convergence between natural units, electron structure, gravitational self-energy, and charged-object extremality. It identifies both the conceptual significance and the experimental limitations of this convergence, while recovering a largely overlooked contribution by Anton Bopp to the relationship between electric charge, mass, and gravitation.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-13
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24127780
Primary Topic
Relativity and Gravitational Theory
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

The Mass of the Charge: From Stoney's Unit to Bopp's Mass of the charge and the Gravitational Self-Energy of a Point Charge

Ulrich Schreier
2 links
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Relativity and Gravitational Theory
article

The Mass of the Charge: From Stoney's Unit to Bopp's Mass of the charge and the Gravitational Self-Energy of a Point Charge

Ulrich Schreier
article en

Abstract

An essay in the making (a preliminary draft is available on demand) The Mass of the Charge From Stoney’s Unit to Bopp’s Masse der Ladung and the Gravitational Self-Energy of a Point Charge Abstract A remarkable mass scale, (MBL= ec/√G ≈ 1.85921 × 10-6) g in CGS–Gaussian units, appears independently in several developments spanning nearly a century and a half of physics. First introduced by George Johnstone Stoney in 1881 as the mass unit of a natural system of units, the same quantity subsequently acquired distinct physical interpretations in Anton Bopp's unpublished manuscripts (1941–1957), in classical general relativity, and in contemporary discussions of quantum gravity. The paper examines four interpretations of this common mass scale: Stoney's natural unit; Bopp's Masse der Ladung(mass of the charge); the gravitationally dressed self-energy of an electrically charged point particle; and the extremal charge-to-mass threshold appearing in Einstein–Maxwell theory and the Weak Gravity Conjecture. Bopp's contribution is of particular historical and conceptual interest. Beginning in 1941, he distinguished the gravitational rest mass of the electron from a mass associated with its electric charge. By 1943, this distinction had become part of his proposed closure condition connecting electromagnetism, gravitation, and the electron's kinetic zero-point energy. In 1957, he explicitly defined the Masse der Ladung through the equality of Newtonian gravitational attraction and Coulomb repulsion. In Bopp's framework, the ratio between the mass of the charge and the electron mass is expressed through the dimensionless electron–gravity coupling, αeG = ec / (me √G) ≈ 2.04098 × 1021 and related to a characteristic zero-point velocity (v_\omega\approx0.66359) cm/s and frequency (νzp ≈ 0.0605390) Hz. These relations form part of the proposed dimensionless closure condition linking the electron's rest energy to its zero-point energy. A striking parallel appears in the 1960 work of Arnowitt, Deser, and Misner, who showed that including gravitational self-energy yields a finite total mass for a classical point charge, equal to (ec / (me √G) and independent of its bare mechanical mass. Related equilibrium and extremality conditions arise in the Majumdar–Papapetrou and Reissner–Nordström solutions, while the Weak Gravity Conjecture introduces the same scale as a charge-to-mass threshold. Although these formulations converge on an identical numerical quantity, they do not establish identical physical interpretations. In particular, none independently determines the observed electron mass, which is smaller than the mass of its charge by approximately twenty-one orders of magnitude. The central question is therefore not the numerical identity itself, which follows algebraically from the constants, but the physical condition that could determine this enormous separation of scales. Bopp's closure offers a candidate relation, whose significance would become experimentally testable only through an independently identifiable zero-point frequency, velocity, or associated observable. By bringing these historically separate developments together, the paper highlights an unusual convergence between natural units, electron structure, gravitational self-energy, and charged-object extremality. It identifies both the conceptual significance and the experimental limitations of this convergence, while recovering a largely overlooked contribution by Anton Bopp to the relationship between electric charge, mass, and gravitation.

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Relativity and Gravitational Theory
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon