Dance Charisma and fan identity in live concerts: a serial-mediation model of kinesthetic empathy, perceived emotional synchrony, and collective effervescence

Introduction Live concerts continue to thrive in an age of digital saturation, suggesting that bodily co-presence resists virtual substitution. We ask how dance charisma relates to a theoretically specified sequence culminating in fan identity. Integrating mirror-neuron theory, emotional contagion, neo-Durkheimian theory, and social identity theory, we propose a serial-mediation model relating dance charisma to social identity through kinesthetic empathy, perceived emotional synchrony, and collective effervescence, with dance experience moderating the charisma-empathy association. The ordering of variables reflects the underlying theory; it is not established by the data. Methods We surveyed 502 Chinese concert-goers aged 18–35 (via Credamo) who had attended a dance-featuring concert in the past year, and analyzed with PLS-SEM (SmartPLS 4.0, bootstrap resampling). A sensitivity analysis adjusting for demographic and attendance covariates is reported alongside the primary model. Results The hypothesized direct and indirect associations were statistically significant. Higher rated charisma went with stronger reported bodily resonance, stronger resonance with greater reported emotional synchrony, and greater synchrony with both a stronger sense of collective effervescence and stronger fan identification. Both serial indirect associations were significant, the longer one running through collective effervescence and the shorter one not including it; absent a formal difference test we treat them as of similar magnitude. The moderation effect was also significant but opposite in direction to that predicted, dance experience weakening rather than strengthening the charisma-resonance association, so that hypothesis was not supported. All focal estimates survived covariate adjustment. Discussion Because the design is cross-sectional and single-source, the pattern describes association rather than causation, and reverse-direction readings remain observationally equivalent. All constructs are individual retrospective self-reports, so neural and collective-level mechanisms remain untested theoretical explanations, and identity formation and stability were not measured. Because the direct synchrony-identification association is estimated with collective effervescence in the model, it indicates that effervescence did not fully account for that relationship, not that identification arises without an effervescent experience. The negative moderation effect was small and is offered as a tentative boundary condition. The findings extend the neo-Durkheimian framework to popular-culture gatherings and position dance charisma as a hypothesized antecedent of reported fan-community belonging.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Frontiers in Psychology
Published
2026-11-13
DOI
https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2026.1873061
Primary Topic
Arts and Performance Studies
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Dance Charisma and fan identity in live concerts: a serial-mediation model of kinesthetic empathy, perceived emotional synchrony, and collective effervescence

Qi Cao, Ziran Zhou, Lin Wang, Yifan Li et al.
2 links
Frontiers in Psychology
Arts and Performance Studies
article

Dance Charisma and fan identity in live concerts: a serial-mediation model of kinesthetic empathy, perceived emotional synchrony, and collective effervescence

Qi Cao, Ziran Zhou, Lin Wang, Yifan Li, Yutong Liu
article en

Abstract

Introduction Live concerts continue to thrive in an age of digital saturation, suggesting that bodily co-presence resists virtual substitution. We ask how dance charisma relates to a theoretically specified sequence culminating in fan identity. Integrating mirror-neuron theory, emotional contagion, neo-Durkheimian theory, and social identity theory, we propose a serial-mediation model relating dance charisma to social identity through kinesthetic empathy, perceived emotional synchrony, and collective effervescence, with dance experience moderating the charisma-empathy association. The ordering of variables reflects the underlying theory; it is not established by the data. Methods We surveyed 502 Chinese concert-goers aged 18–35 (via Credamo) who had attended a dance-featuring concert in the past year, and analyzed with PLS-SEM (SmartPLS 4.0, bootstrap resampling). A sensitivity analysis adjusting for demographic and attendance covariates is reported alongside the primary model. Results The hypothesized direct and indirect associations were statistically significant. Higher rated charisma went with stronger reported bodily resonance, stronger resonance with greater reported emotional synchrony, and greater synchrony with both a stronger sense of collective effervescence and stronger fan identification. Both serial indirect associations were significant, the longer one running through collective effervescence and the shorter one not including it; absent a formal difference test we treat them as of similar magnitude. The moderation effect was also significant but opposite in direction to that predicted, dance experience weakening rather than strengthening the charisma-resonance association, so that hypothesis was not supported. All focal estimates survived covariate adjustment. Discussion Because the design is cross-sectional and single-source, the pattern describes association rather than causation, and reverse-direction readings remain observationally equivalent. All constructs are individual retrospective self-reports, so neural and collective-level mechanisms remain untested theoretical explanations, and identity formation and stability were not measured. Because the direct synchrony-identification association is estimated with collective effervescence in the model, it indicates that effervescence did not fully account for that relationship, not that identification arises without an effervescent experience. The negative moderation effect was small and is offered as a tentative boundary condition. The findings extend the neo-Durkheimian framework to popular-culture gatherings and position dance charisma as a hypothesized antecedent of reported fan-community belonging.

Frontiers in PsychologyVol. 17
National University of Singapore (SG), Shandong Xiehe University (CN), Hanyang University (KR)
Arts and Performance Studies
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon