Value-Added Tax and Organizational Neutrality in Coalition Loyalty Reward Programs: Differential Effects on SME Participation and Impact on Social Welfare
Abstract This paper asks whether Korea’s VAT treatment of cross-firm reward-point redemption is organizationally neutral. Points used with their issuer may reduce the taxable amount, while reimbursements for points issued by another firm are generally included in the redeemer’s taxable amount. Under stated assumptions, total output VAT may be higher when a similar reward crosses a firm boundary, though the inter-firm reimbursement may justify the difference. The paper’s central mechanism is administrative: VAT adds classification, invoicing, period-matching, correction, retention, and penalty-control work to ordinary settlement, and the fixed member- or relationship-specific component of that work can weigh more heavily on low-volume SMEs under four stated conditions. Welfare effects follow two tracks: efficiency costs requiring no market failure, and competition-related harm requiring benefits the coalition cannot capture. The paper suggests administrative simplification within the current base and treats base-level reforms as provisional options requiring legislation and safeguards.
Authors
- Min Joon Park
Publication Details
- Journal
- Asian Journal of Law and Economics
- Published
- 2026-11-13
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.1515/ajle-2026-0077
- Primary Topic
- Taxation and Legal Issues
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00