QITE DIAL: measurement-altered quantum criticality with an adjustable measurement strength, on rings of 12 and 20 superconducting qubits. A registered experiment

A quantum critical state has correlations on all length scales, and theory predicts that measuring part of such a state weakly, and keeping one outcome, changes the power law with which the correlations of the rest decay, continuously with the strength of the measurement (Garratt, Weinstein and Altman, Phys. Rev. X 13, 021026; Weinstein et al., Phys. Rev. B 107, 245132; Murciano et al., Phys. Rev. X 13, 041042). For the critical Ising chain a measurement of the transverse field and a measurement of the bond energy, which are exchanged by the Kramers-Wannier duality, move the exponent in opposite directions. A recent roadmap for Rydberg arrays (arXiv:2506.21963) describes the experimental validation as an open problem; a literature search on the day of the run found no reported observation. This deposit holds a registered experiment on a public quantum processor. On the IBM Heron processor ibm_fez a ring of 12 qubits (one hexagon of the lattice) and a ring of 20 qubits (the perimeter of two adjacent hexagons) are prepared near the ground state of the critical transverse-field Ising ring with N/2 layers of ZZ and X rotations (144 and 400 CZ gates, every CZ twirled) and read out in four settings. The strength of the measurement is a dial that is turned after the fact: on qubits that are read anyway, a weak measurement with a selected outcome is identical to a weighting of the projective shots with exp(strength x sum of the outcomes), so every strength is evaluated from the same shots, without ancilla qubits, mid-circuit measurements or discarded shots. The registered quantity is the dial D: the slope of the correlations against distance, on logarithmic axes, under the field measurement minus the slope under the bond measurement. The rings were chosen at submission by a registered rule from the calibration of the moment. Lines, bands, the layout rule and the analysis were fixed and hashed before the first job (registration SHA-256 25b81a10fe1be08bfc0a700711724cdbe30ec87a3439a906800340f094b38fb3). Results, as they fell: 128 circuits, 1,032,000 shots, 8 jobs run back to back in five minutes, 288 s of QPU time. At strength 1.0 the dial is D = -0.357 +- 0.015 on 12 qubits and -0.358 +- 0.017 on 20 qubits (exact values of the critical ring: -0.328 and -0.333), more than 20 standard errors from zero and the same on both rings; at the four registered strengths it lies within two standard errors of the exact value; without weighting it is +0.026 +- 0.013 and -0.005 +- 0.014. A fault-free 20-qubit ring 5 % off the critical field would give -0.20 or -0.50, eight to ten standard errors away. All eight binding lines and the three attestation lines held. What is not shown: the two slopes taken separately. The faults of the processor attenuate the correlations to between 20 and 57 % of their exact size, the weighting also filters faulty shots, and the field measurement alone does not show the predicted steepening; that the faults cancel in the difference is taken from a noise model, and supported by the two rings, whose states are attenuated very differently, giving the same dial. At strong weighting the dial is about 0.03 deeper than the exact value on both rings, and the ratio of the two correlation curves lies a few per cent below the exact ratio. The strength is applied in the analysis; no weak measurement took place on the processor. The rings have 12 and 20 sites, the prediction tested is the exact one for these sizes, and nothing here is a claim of quantum advantage. The deposit holds the registration, the module with the angles, the layout rule, the circuits, the estimator and the lines, the session script, the verdict script, the registration script with its Monte Carlo, the script of the noise models and the eight model distributions, the script and the log of a preliminary look on the device, the session log with the bits of every shot of every circuit, the verdict (formed once), the ledger, a rehearsal of the whole session on the noiseless simulator under the hashed registration, the write-up (qite_dial_paper_v1.pdf) and the scripts and figures that build it. Licence: CC BY 4.0.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-13
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24208006
Primary Topic
Quantum many-body systems
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

QITE DIAL: measurement-altered quantum criticality with an adjustable measurement strength, on rings of 12 and 20 superconducting qubits. A registered experiment

Bernd Westrick
1 links
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Quantum many-body systems
article

QITE DIAL: measurement-altered quantum criticality with an adjustable measurement strength, on rings of 12 and 20 superconducting qubits. A registered experiment

Bernd Westrick
article en

Abstract

A quantum critical state has correlations on all length scales, and theory predicts that measuring part of such a state weakly, and keeping one outcome, changes the power law with which the correlations of the rest decay, continuously with the strength of the measurement (Garratt, Weinstein and Altman, Phys. Rev. X 13, 021026; Weinstein et al., Phys. Rev. B 107, 245132; Murciano et al., Phys. Rev. X 13, 041042). For the critical Ising chain a measurement of the transverse field and a measurement of the bond energy, which are exchanged by the Kramers-Wannier duality, move the exponent in opposite directions. A recent roadmap for Rydberg arrays (arXiv:2506.21963) describes the experimental validation as an open problem; a literature search on the day of the run found no reported observation. This deposit holds a registered experiment on a public quantum processor. On the IBM Heron processor ibm_fez a ring of 12 qubits (one hexagon of the lattice) and a ring of 20 qubits (the perimeter of two adjacent hexagons) are prepared near the ground state of the critical transverse-field Ising ring with N/2 layers of ZZ and X rotations (144 and 400 CZ gates, every CZ twirled) and read out in four settings. The strength of the measurement is a dial that is turned after the fact: on qubits that are read anyway, a weak measurement with a selected outcome is identical to a weighting of the projective shots with exp(strength x sum of the outcomes), so every strength is evaluated from the same shots, without ancilla qubits, mid-circuit measurements or discarded shots. The registered quantity is the dial D: the slope of the correlations against distance, on logarithmic axes, under the field measurement minus the slope under the bond measurement. The rings were chosen at submission by a registered rule from the calibration of the moment. Lines, bands, the layout rule and the analysis were fixed and hashed before the first job (registration SHA-256 25b81a10fe1be08bfc0a700711724cdbe30ec87a3439a906800340f094b38fb3). Results, as they fell: 128 circuits, 1,032,000 shots, 8 jobs run back to back in five minutes, 288 s of QPU time. At strength 1.0 the dial is D = -0.357 +- 0.015 on 12 qubits and -0.358 +- 0.017 on 20 qubits (exact values of the critical ring: -0.328 and -0.333), more than 20 standard errors from zero and the same on both rings; at the four registered strengths it lies within two standard errors of the exact value; without weighting it is +0.026 +- 0.013 and -0.005 +- 0.014. A fault-free 20-qubit ring 5 % off the critical field would give -0.20 or -0.50, eight to ten standard errors away. All eight binding lines and the three attestation lines held. What is not shown: the two slopes taken separately. The faults of the processor attenuate the correlations to between 20 and 57 % of their exact size, the weighting also filters faulty shots, and the field measurement alone does not show the predicted steepening; that the faults cancel in the difference is taken from a noise model, and supported by the two rings, whose states are attenuated very differently, giving the same dial. At strong weighting the dial is about 0.03 deeper than the exact value on both rings, and the ratio of the two correlation curves lies a few per cent below the exact ratio. The strength is applied in the analysis; no weak measurement took place on the processor. The rings have 12 and 20 sites, the prediction tested is the exact one for these sizes, and nothing here is a claim of quantum advantage. The deposit holds the registration, the module with the angles, the layout rule, the circuits, the estimator and the lines, the session script, the verdict script, the registration script with its Monte Carlo, the script of the noise models and the eight model distributions, the script and the log of a preliminary look on the device, the session log with the bits of every shot of every circuit, the verdict (formed once), the ledger, a rehearsal of the whole session on the noiseless simulator under the hashed registration, the write-up (qite_dial_paper_v1.pdf) and the scripts and figures that build it. Licence: CC BY 4.0.

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Quantum many-body systems
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon