Confronting the Evils of Extraction: Keeping Climate Ethics Engaged
Abstract The two fundamental contentions of this article are that grave evil is systematically being done and that the perpetrators have great entrenched political power based in their carbon wealth that can be overcome only by broad coalitions of politically active individuals. Since the evil consists of threats to the preconditions of civilized society, all humans have both strong self-interest and an unconditional duty to resist it and defend our way of life. This makes the broad coalitions that are necessary also possible. Since the perpetrators are politically powerful, resisting the threats they pose requires challenging their power and undermining their wealth. No firm can be allowed any longer simply to proceed to make climate change worse because it fits their established business model. Climate ethics has so far focused mainly on questions of justice and fairness - the ethics of cooperation. We need also to develop an ethics of confrontation, beginning with a lucid understanding of the supreme moral importance of what is at stake in this political struggle over whether the extractive business-as-usual can be permitted to continue on its own terms and, since it cannot, over how it can best be eliminated fast enough, We will see some basis in both political economy and recent experience to believe that, for example, concerted political action by broad political coalitions can overcome opposition and mobilize public institutions. But a much fuller ethically-infused and empirically-based strategy is needed for the great political battle of our time.
Authors
- Henry Shue (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7646-7414)
Institutions
- University of Oxford (GB)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Research Square
- Published
- 2026-11-13
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11539006/v1
- Primary Topic
- Environmental Philosophy and Ethics
- Type
- preprint