Partnerships for development: collaborative governance in blended finance strategies in Brazil
Purpose This study aims to examine how antecedent and initial conditions of collaborative governance combine to shape the approval of consortium proposals in blended finance. Using the first BNDES Blended Finance Fund in Brazil, it asks which combinations of organizational resources, expertise, prior relationships and sectoral diversity make consortia more credible to a development finance institution. The study addresses a gap in research on the organizational and relational conditions that precede partnership formation and influence access to development finance. Design/methodology/approach The study applies fuzzy-set Qualitative Comparative Analysis (fsQCA) to 27 consortia competing in the BNDES call, eight of which were approved. Six conditions were analyzed: social entrepreneurship expertise, financial expertise, diversity of capital sources, prior relationship with BNDES, sustainability expertise and sectoral diversity. Organizational data were coded from websites and activity reports, aggregated at consortium level and calibrated into set memberships. Necessity and sufficiency analyses were complemented by robustness tests across alternative calibrations and analytical thresholds. Findings Approval is associated with a stable configurational backbone combining social entrepreneurship expertise, capital diversity, prior ties with BNDES, sustainability expertise and sectoral diversity. Sectoral diversity is the condition closest to necessity and becomes necessary under alternative calibrations. Rejection is more equifinal and follows multiple pathways, but the absence of sectoral diversity recurs across all specifications. Financial expertise is not a stable component of approval: its role changes with analytical thresholds, while financially sophisticated but thematically weak or sectorally closed coalitions are consistently associated with non-approval. Research limitations/implications The analysis concerns the selection stage of a single BNDES call and relies on observable organizational attributes, potentially understating informal capabilities and internal governance practices. With 27 cases and six conditions, the study also has limited generalizability despite covering the analyzed proposal universe and conducting robustness tests. Approval may partly reflect BNDES-specific policy preferences, while factors such as project quality, territorial fit and leadership remain unmodeled. Future research should compare programs and countries and track how initial configurations translate into implementation performance and impact. Practical implications Public development banks can treat sectoral diversity as a design criterion rather than merely a scoring bonus, require governance charters defining decision rules and accountability and monitor whether formal diversity produces effective participation. Matchmaking and capacity-building can reduce advantages enjoyed by organizations with prior funder relationships. Applicants should document verifiable socio-environmental experience, while financial intermediaries should partner with mission-driven organizations and adopt governance arrangements that genuinely share authority. Technical assistance and blended-structuring support can help manage the coordination costs created by diverse partnerships. Social implications The findings show that blended finance allocation is also a governance and equity issue. Requiring broader sectoral participation can reduce closed, technocratic coalitions, limit concentration of influence and improve representation of organizations connected to beneficiary communities. Measures that lower entry barriers for actors without prior relationships with development banks can broaden access to public-backed finance. By linking composition, participation and accountability requirements to financing decisions, development institutions can better align blended finance with the public-purpose ambitions of SDG 17 and the equity objectives of SDG 10. Originality/value The study connects collaborative governance theory with the selection stage of blended finance, an area in which antecedent conditions remain underexplored. It shows empirically that actor composition functions as an implicit governance mechanism: funders select not only projects but configurations expected to sustain legitimacy, trust and joint action. The configurational approach reveals an important asymmetry – approval requires a relatively narrow bundle of strengths, whereas rejection can arise through several pathways – and clarifies that financial expertise has conditional rather than independent value when not accompanied by sectoral openness and thematic legitimacy.
Authors
- Pietro Rodrigues (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8153-0104)
- Felipe Jukemura (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1757-2147)
Institutions
- Instituto Pensi (BR)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Revista de Administração de Empresas
- Published
- 2026-11-13
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.1108/rae-08-2026-0400
- Primary Topic
- Community Development and Social Impact
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00