Legitimation Manipulation in Political Argumentation: A Cognitive Critical Comparative Analysis on Energy Policy Discourse of the Democratic Party and the Republicn Party
Abstract Energy has become a global issue and the U.S.’ energy policy remains volatile as the Democratic party and the Republican have different stances on energy. This article constructs a three-dimensional theoretical framework: strategy-argumentation-critique, which combines representation, action and critique together. The proximization and distanciation are integrated together into symbolic distance strategies which are used to adjust the distance between outside-deictic center and inside-deictic center. And the symbolic distance strategies are used to manipulate the public’s construal mechanism in the process of argumentation or deliberation leading to decision and action. Finally the critique of argumentation can disclose the rightfulness and wrongness which can contribute to the social development. Therefore, this article, taking the energy part of Economic Report of the President as data, analyzes how the two parties deliberate their own energy action in the practical argumentation, explores how they use symbolic distance strategies in the argumentation to achieve their rhetorical effects, and offers a critical analysis of the argumentation to reveal the ideologies and stances of the two party reflected in their discourse.
Authors
- Fangying Gong
- Min Chen
Publication Details
- Journal
- Research Square
- Published
- 2026-11-13
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11590623/v1
- Primary Topic
- Cultural and political discourse analysis
- Type
- preprint