Intraoperative failure of the robotic workflow in spine surgery: incidence, failure modes and predictors of conversion to freehand or navigated technique. A systematic review and meta-analysis of proportions

Abstract Purpose. Robot-assisted spine surgery has been assessed almost entirely through pedicle screw accuracy. Intraoperative conversion to freehand or navigated technique has not been synthesised as a primary outcome. We estimated its incidence, applied a pre-specified failure-mode taxonomy and examined predictors of conversion. Methods. Systematic review and meta-analysis of proportions, registered on PROSPERO before searching. MEDLINE, Europe PMC and Cochrane CENTRAL were searched on 18 September 2026 using a robot-and-spine strategy with a workflow-failure overlay. Clinical series of ten or more patients reporting a conversion numerator with a matched denominator were eligible; overlapping cohorts were collapsed. Random-effects logit DerSimonian–Laird models estimated per-case any conversion (Grade 2 or 3) and Grade 3 total abandonment, with Clopper–Pearson study intervals and 95% prediction intervals. Series silent on conversion were not treated as reporting zero. Results. Thirteen independent sources (2,728 robot-attempted cases) entered the per-case models. Pooled any-conversion incidence was 3.6% (95% CI 2.1–6.3) with a 95% prediction interval of 0.5–23.6% (I² 81%). Most contributing numerators capture total abandonment only, so 3.6% is a lower bound on the primary outcome rather than an estimate of it. Grade 3 abandonment was 2.8% (1.7–4.6; 95% PI 0.6–13.2). Sources including the first institutional cases pooled at 7.1% (4.5–11.0) against 1.4% (0.8–2.6) in later or larger series. First-generation Mazor platforms pooled higher than third-generation Mazor and floor-mounted ExcelsiusGPS. Registration and tracking accounted for 57% and the instrument–bone interface for 23% of 74 classified mechanisms; that denominator is stated mechanisms and not the 76 case-level conversion events, and a single source contributes 20 of the 74, so these percentages must not be applied to case counts. Conclusion. A single pooled percentage is not sufficient for procurement planning. The prediction intervals, and not the pooled values of 3.6% and 2.8%, are the planning figures: conversion in a new series is compatible with anything between approximately 1 in 200 cases and 1 in 4, and most of that spread reflects platform generation and operator experience. Certainty in the pooled incidence is very low. Accuracy estimates that exclude converted screws overstate what the device delivers in practice.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Research Square
Published
2026-11-13
DOI
https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11128619/v1
Primary Topic
Spinal Fractures and Fixation Techniques
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Intraoperative failure of the robotic workflow in spine surgery: incidence, failure modes and predictors of conversion to freehand or navigated technique. A systematic review and meta-analysis of proportions

André Chou, Birender Balain, Aashish Ghodke, S. Singh et al.
2 links
Research Square
Spinal Fractures and Fixation Techniques
preprint

Intraoperative failure of the robotic workflow in spine surgery: incidence, failure modes and predictors of conversion to freehand or navigated technique. A systematic review and meta-analysis of proportions

André Chou, Birender Balain, Aashish Ghodke, S. Singh, Rishi Agarwal
preprint en

Abstract

Abstract Purpose. Robot-assisted spine surgery has been assessed almost entirely through pedicle screw accuracy. Intraoperative conversion to freehand or navigated technique has not been synthesised as a primary outcome. We estimated its incidence, applied a pre-specified failure-mode taxonomy and examined predictors of conversion. Methods. Systematic review and meta-analysis of proportions, registered on PROSPERO before searching. MEDLINE, Europe PMC and Cochrane CENTRAL were searched on 18 September 2026 using a robot-and-spine strategy with a workflow-failure overlay. Clinical series of ten or more patients reporting a conversion numerator with a matched denominator were eligible; overlapping cohorts were collapsed. Random-effects logit DerSimonian–Laird models estimated per-case any conversion (Grade 2 or 3) and Grade 3 total abandonment, with Clopper–Pearson study intervals and 95% prediction intervals. Series silent on conversion were not treated as reporting zero. Results. Thirteen independent sources (2,728 robot-attempted cases) entered the per-case models. Pooled any-conversion incidence was 3.6% (95% CI 2.1–6.3) with a 95% prediction interval of 0.5–23.6% (I² 81%). Most contributing numerators capture total abandonment only, so 3.6% is a lower bound on the primary outcome rather than an estimate of it. Grade 3 abandonment was 2.8% (1.7–4.6; 95% PI 0.6–13.2). Sources including the first institutional cases pooled at 7.1% (4.5–11.0) against 1.4% (0.8–2.6) in later or larger series. First-generation Mazor platforms pooled higher than third-generation Mazor and floor-mounted ExcelsiusGPS. Registration and tracking accounted for 57% and the instrument–bone interface for 23% of 74 classified mechanisms; that denominator is stated mechanisms and not the 76 case-level conversion events, and a single source contributes 20 of the 74, so these percentages must not be applied to case counts. Conclusion. A single pooled percentage is not sufficient for procurement planning. The prediction intervals, and not the pooled values of 3.6% and 2.8%, are the planning figures: conversion in a new series is compatible with anything between approximately 1 in 200 cases and 1 in 4, and most of that spread reflects platform generation and operator experience. Certainty in the pooled incidence is very low. Accuracy estimates that exclude converted screws overstate what the device delivers in practice.

Research Square
Cardiff and Vale University Health Board (GB), Royal Gwent Hospital (GB), University Hospital of Wales (GB), Robert Jones and Agnes Hunt Orthopaedic Hospital (GB), Robert Jones and Agnes Hunt Orthopaedic Hospital NHS Trust (GB)
Good health and well-being
Spinal Fractures and Fixation Techniques
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon