Rapid Cycling-Mediated Indirect Facilitation: A Formal Hypothesis on the Maintenance of Plankton Diversity
Abstract The paradox of the plankton---that coexisting species vastly outnumber limiting resource types---has lacked a formal explanation that simultaneously embeds classical competition theory and niche theory since Hutchinson. This paper proposes a hypothesis: in plankton communities, rapid material cycling transforms the resource pool from a passive sink assumed by competition theory into a cycling medium in which biomass temporarily hosts resources. When a species consumes a resource, the resource does not vanish; it merely transfers from the inorganic pool to the biomass pool. When that species dies and is remineralized, the resource immediately returns to the inorganic pool and becomes available to other species. This cycling feedback produces interspecific indirect facilitation at long time scales, with strength proportional to mortality rate $\delta_i$ and stoichiometric fraction $\mu_{ji}$, competing against consumption rate $V_{ji}f_i$. When $\mu_{ji}\delta_i > V_{ji}f_i$ for all resources, the net effect of niche overlap shifts from competition to facilitation, and the conclusions of classical competitive exclusion are revised. The criterion is a sufficient condition: if it holds for some resources but not others, the net effect may still be positive. At equilibrium, the criterion takes the form $\mu_{ji}r_i > V_{ji}$, and the two are limits of the same criterion at different time scales. We further situate this mechanism within the classical literature of the microbial loop, provide a strict mathematical definition of the ''unified coupled population'' concept and three testable emergent properties, distinguish it from the storage effect, viral lysis explanations, and the quasi-optimal resource mechanism, and address evolutionary stability. A simple evolutionary model is provided to show how Red Queen dynamics can sustain high mortality rates. Each testable prediction is accompanied by runnable Python code, available at \url{https://github.com/mldih/Planktion-1}. The value of this hypothesis does not lie in being proven, but in advancing the plankton paradox from a qualitative debate to a measurable, computable, and falsifiable formal framework.
Authors
- Hao Duan
Publication Details
- Journal
- Research Square
- Published
- 2026-11-13
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11306961/v1
- Primary Topic
- Mathematical and Theoretical Epidemiology and Ecology Models
- Type
- preprint