From Observation to Welfare Inference in the Domestic Horse: Biological Context, Converging Evidence and Temporal Trajectories

Equine welfare assessment requires interpretation of behavioural, clinical, physiological and contextual data to infer welfare-relevant mental experiences. Contemporary welfare frameworks already organise conditions relevant to both negative and positive welfare. Recent care frameworks distinguish care and management practices from their intended effects on the animal’s affective state. They also place greater emphasis on meaningful choice and agency. This structured critical narrative review proposes the Equine Welfare Inference Framework (EWIF) as a complementary reasoning framework for a narrower problem: how to make the evidential pathway and the confidence in a welfare interpretation explicit when findings are incomplete, partly redundant, discordant or time-dependent. EWIF does not claim novelty for the individual principles of considering alternatives, multiple indicators, context or longitudinal change; its proposed contribution is their explicit integration around the sequence from finding to biological process, candidate internal state, welfare interpretation and confidence. Exploratory searches were followed by 34 predefined PubMed searches, yielding 6098 search-result occurrences and 4071 unique records after deduplication. Sensitivity-preserving screening retained 2274 records as a broad evidence reservoir for source discovery and conceptual coverage; these records were not a conventional set of studies, were not all independently assessed in full text, and did not contribute equally to the framework. Central claims underwent targeted source-level checks, with coverage and access limitations considered in the interpretation of the evidence. EWIF applies symmetrically to proposed positive and negative states: it asks whether additional findings provide genuinely independent support, whether disagreement reflects timing or different biological processes, and how responses change and resolve over time. It can be applied across ridden and driven exercise, handling, veterinary procedures, transport, routine management and breeding without replacing context-specific instruments. EWIF is a conceptual framework that requires empirical testing for reproducibility and practical value.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Animals
Published
2026-11-13
DOI
https://doi.org/10.3390/ani16223597
Primary Topic
Veterinary Equine Medical Research
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

From Observation to Welfare Inference in the Domestic Horse: Biological Context, Converging Evidence and Temporal Trajectories

Tünay Karan, Rene van den HOVEN, Ali Cesur Onmaz, Çağrı Çağlar Sinmez
1 links
Animals
Veterinary Equine Medical Research
article

From Observation to Welfare Inference in the Domestic Horse: Biological Context, Converging Evidence and Temporal Trajectories

Tünay Karan, Rene van den HOVEN, Ali Cesur Onmaz, Çağrı Çağlar Sinmez
article en

Abstract

Equine welfare assessment requires interpretation of behavioural, clinical, physiological and contextual data to infer welfare-relevant mental experiences. Contemporary welfare frameworks already organise conditions relevant to both negative and positive welfare. Recent care frameworks distinguish care and management practices from their intended effects on the animal’s affective state. They also place greater emphasis on meaningful choice and agency. This structured critical narrative review proposes the Equine Welfare Inference Framework (EWIF) as a complementary reasoning framework for a narrower problem: how to make the evidential pathway and the confidence in a welfare interpretation explicit when findings are incomplete, partly redundant, discordant or time-dependent. EWIF does not claim novelty for the individual principles of considering alternatives, multiple indicators, context or longitudinal change; its proposed contribution is their explicit integration around the sequence from finding to biological process, candidate internal state, welfare interpretation and confidence. Exploratory searches were followed by 34 predefined PubMed searches, yielding 6098 search-result occurrences and 4071 unique records after deduplication. Sensitivity-preserving screening retained 2274 records as a broad evidence reservoir for source discovery and conceptual coverage; these records were not a conventional set of studies, were not all independently assessed in full text, and did not contribute equally to the framework. Central claims underwent targeted source-level checks, with coverage and access limitations considered in the interpretation of the evidence. EWIF applies symmetrically to proposed positive and negative states: it asks whether additional findings provide genuinely independent support, whether disagreement reflects timing or different biological processes, and how responses change and resolve over time. It can be applied across ridden and driven exercise, handling, veterinary procedures, transport, routine management and breeding without replacing context-specific instruments. EWIF is a conceptual framework that requires empirical testing for reproducibility and practical value.

AnimalsVol. 16(22)
University of Veterinary Medicine Vienna (AT), Yozgat Bozok Üniversitesi (TR), Erciyes University (TR)
Veterinary Equine Medical Research
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon