Bank soundness of listed private national commercial banks under the RGEC Framework: A comparison of OCBC NISP, Danamon, and Permata, 2023–2025

Transparent and reproducible comparisons of private national commercial banks under Indonesia's risk-based bank rating approach remain scarce for the post-pandemic period. This study assesses and compares the soundness of three listed private national commercial banks (OCBC NISP, Danamon, and Permata) for 2023–2025 and tests whether the comparison is sensitive to how indicator ratings are combined into a composite score. A descriptive quantitative design applies a partial RGEC screening on six indicators: NPL and LDR (Risk Profile), the governance self-assessment composite rating (Good Corporate Governance), ROA and BOPO (Earnings), and CAR (Capital). Consolidated annual-report data are rated under the current risk-based bank rating regulation, and equal-weight and risk-weighted composite scores are compared. OCBC NISP achieved the highest composite score in every year under both weighting schemes, supported by the lowest LDR and the top governance rating. Danamon's score improved as its LDR declined, whereas Permata's fell in 2025 as its LDR rose. All three banks remained very healthy on BOPO and CAR. Danamon's and Permata's standing against the “very healthy” threshold depends on the weighting scheme. Differences thus lie in credit and liquidity risk and self-assessed governance, not in cost efficiency or capital adequacy. Danamon and Permata should sustain deposit growth ahead of loan growth; investors should not read composite scores as a single settled ranking; regulators could standardize bank-only ratio disclosure. The study provides current, reproducible, and sensitivity-tested evidence on risk-based soundness assessment of foreign-affiliated private national commercial banks.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
The Contrarian Finance Accounting and Business Research
Published
2026-11-13
DOI
https://doi.org/10.58784/cfabr.528
Primary Topic
Banking stability, regulation, efficiency
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Bank soundness of listed private national commercial banks under the RGEC Framework: A comparison of OCBC NISP, Danamon, and Permata, 2023–2025

Sherly Pinatik, Jullie Jeanette Sondakh, Revalina Hutabarat
The Contrarian Finance Accounting and Business Research
Banking stability, regulation, efficiency
article

Bank soundness of listed private national commercial banks under the RGEC Framework: A comparison of OCBC NISP, Danamon, and Permata, 2023–2025

Sherly Pinatik, Jullie Jeanette Sondakh, Revalina Hutabarat
article en

Abstract

Transparent and reproducible comparisons of private national commercial banks under Indonesia's risk-based bank rating approach remain scarce for the post-pandemic period. This study assesses and compares the soundness of three listed private national commercial banks (OCBC NISP, Danamon, and Permata) for 2023–2025 and tests whether the comparison is sensitive to how indicator ratings are combined into a composite score. A descriptive quantitative design applies a partial RGEC screening on six indicators: NPL and LDR (Risk Profile), the governance self-assessment composite rating (Good Corporate Governance), ROA and BOPO (Earnings), and CAR (Capital). Consolidated annual-report data are rated under the current risk-based bank rating regulation, and equal-weight and risk-weighted composite scores are compared. OCBC NISP achieved the highest composite score in every year under both weighting schemes, supported by the lowest LDR and the top governance rating. Danamon's score improved as its LDR declined, whereas Permata's fell in 2025 as its LDR rose. All three banks remained very healthy on BOPO and CAR. Danamon's and Permata's standing against the “very healthy” threshold depends on the weighting scheme. Differences thus lie in credit and liquidity risk and self-assessed governance, not in cost efficiency or capital adequacy. Danamon and Permata should sustain deposit growth ahead of loan growth; investors should not read composite scores as a single settled ranking; regulators could standardize bank-only ratio disclosure. The study provides current, reproducible, and sensitivity-tested evidence on risk-based soundness assessment of foreign-affiliated private national commercial banks.

The Contrarian Finance Accounting and Business ResearchVol. 5(2)
Sam Ratulangi University (ID)
Banking stability, regulation, efficiency
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon