Non-Injective Truth Evaluation: The Sign-Erasure Fallacy in Classical Conditionals and Counterpossibles A Multiplicative Tri-Valued Relevance Calculus over {+1, −1, 0}

In elementary arithmetic, inferring 1 = −1 from the identities 1×1 = 1 and (−1)×(−1) =1 is a standard fallacy because squaring is a non-injective operation that erases inputsign polarity. This paper demonstrates that classical truth-functional logic and standardpossible-worlds counterfactual semantics commit an isomorphic structural error—termedthe Sign-Erasure Fallacy—when evaluating conditional propositions. By compressingboth grounded truth preservation (T → T) and double-falsehood vacuity (F → F) intoan indistinguishable monolithic output value (True), classical material implication erasesthe epistemic and ontological polarity of its inputs. While David Lewis’s possible-worldssemantics avoids this collapse for contingent falsehoods, it reproduces the exact samenon-injective erasure across counterpossibles (conditionals with impossible antecedents),certifying arbitrary pairs of impossibilities as trivially true. Conversely, unrelated true-to-true conditionals generate unearned redundancy without inferential connection. To resolvethis dual asymmetry, we formalize a Tri-Valued Philosophical Logic Calculus overthe polarity domain V = {+1, −1, 0} integrated with an objective HyperintensionalRelevance Filter RK(A, B) ∈ {0, 1}, governed by the unified multiplicative valuation ruleV (A ⇒ B) = vΦ(A) × RK(A, B) × vΦ(B). Under this operator, only inferentially connectedtruth pairings (+1, 1, +1) and coherent counterfactual dependencies (−1, 1, −1) yield Truth(+1), refuted claims (+1, 1, −1) and causal inversions (−1, 1, +1) yield Falsity (−1), andany irrelevant pairing (RK = 0) or impossible/empty component (vΦ = 0) halts evaluationat No Conclusion / Unknown (0).Keywords: Sign-Erasure Fallacy; Counterpossibles; Three-Valued Logic; HyperintensionalRelevance; Material Implication; Non-Injective Truth Valuation; Impossible Worlds; VacuousTruth.MSC 2020: 03B50 (Many-valued logic); 03B45 (Modal logic); 03B65 (Logic of naturallanguages).

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-13
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24190086
Primary Topic
Logic, Reasoning, and Knowledge
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Non-Injective Truth Evaluation: The Sign-Erasure Fallacy in Classical Conditionals and Counterpossibles A Multiplicative Tri-Valued Relevance Calculus over {+1, −1, 0}

Ravinder Kumar
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Logic, Reasoning, and Knowledge
preprint

Non-Injective Truth Evaluation: The Sign-Erasure Fallacy in Classical Conditionals and Counterpossibles A Multiplicative Tri-Valued Relevance Calculus over {+1, −1, 0}

Ravinder Kumar
preprint en

Abstract

In elementary arithmetic, inferring 1 = −1 from the identities 1×1 = 1 and (−1)×(−1) =1 is a standard fallacy because squaring is a non-injective operation that erases inputsign polarity. This paper demonstrates that classical truth-functional logic and standardpossible-worlds counterfactual semantics commit an isomorphic structural error—termedthe Sign-Erasure Fallacy—when evaluating conditional propositions. By compressingboth grounded truth preservation (T → T) and double-falsehood vacuity (F → F) intoan indistinguishable monolithic output value (True), classical material implication erasesthe epistemic and ontological polarity of its inputs. While David Lewis’s possible-worldssemantics avoids this collapse for contingent falsehoods, it reproduces the exact samenon-injective erasure across counterpossibles (conditionals with impossible antecedents),certifying arbitrary pairs of impossibilities as trivially true. Conversely, unrelated true-to-true conditionals generate unearned redundancy without inferential connection. To resolvethis dual asymmetry, we formalize a Tri-Valued Philosophical Logic Calculus overthe polarity domain V = {+1, −1, 0} integrated with an objective HyperintensionalRelevance Filter RK(A, B) ∈ {0, 1}, governed by the unified multiplicative valuation ruleV (A ⇒ B) = vΦ(A) × RK(A, B) × vΦ(B). Under this operator, only inferentially connectedtruth pairings (+1, 1, +1) and coherent counterfactual dependencies (−1, 1, −1) yield Truth(+1), refuted claims (+1, 1, −1) and causal inversions (−1, 1, +1) yield Falsity (−1), andany irrelevant pairing (RK = 0) or impossible/empty component (vΦ = 0) halts evaluationat No Conclusion / Unknown (0).Keywords: Sign-Erasure Fallacy; Counterpossibles; Three-Valued Logic; HyperintensionalRelevance; Material Implication; Non-Injective Truth Valuation; Impossible Worlds; VacuousTruth.MSC 2020: 03B50 (Many-valued logic); 03B45 (Modal logic); 03B65 (Logic of naturallanguages).

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Logic, Reasoning, and Knowledge
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon