Politics of Waste: A Critique of Bandung City Government’s Approach to Waste Governance

ABSTRACT Bandung's chronic waste problem illustrates that urban environmental governance is shaped as much by bureaucratic worldview as by material capacity. Daily waste output of roughly 1,500 to 1,700 tonnes continues to be met with administrative fixes and engineering responses, leaving the deeper socio-political drivers of the crisis largely unaddressed. Drawing on Dryzek's notion of administrative rationalism, this paper investigates how a technocratic mode of reasoning has come to dominate the Bandung City Government's waste policymaking, and considers the political, institutional, and structural conditions that sustain a recurring cycle of crisis. The study relies on a qualitative literature review combined with discourse analysis and an institutional lens, examining official policy documents alongside scholarly work on urban solid-waste governance. Findings show that the city's response continues to privilege short-horizon technical fixes, among them fleet expansion and landfill enlargement, while social dimensions, behavioural change, and genuine citizen involvement remain secondary concerns. Fragmented coordination among agencies, weak policy integration, and constrained institutional capacity compound this stagnation. The paper argues for a discursive shift away from top-down technocracy toward a more deliberative, participatory, and collaborative governance model, one capable of moving waste policy beyond reactive crisis management toward a structurally grounded and sustainable resolution. Keywords: Waste governance; Administrative rationalism; Urban solid-waste management; Institutional perspective; Bandung ABSTRAK Krisis persampahan di Kota Bandung menjadi bukti bahwa persoalan lingkungan perkotaan bukan semata perkara keterbatasan sarana dan prasarana, melainkan juga produk dari cara pemerintah memaknai dan merumuskan masalah tersebut. Dengan volume timbulan harian yang berkisar antara 1.500 hingga 1.700 ton, kebijakan yang diambil pemerintah kota masih berkutat pada penyelesaian administratif dan rekayasa teknis, sehingga akar persoalan sosial-politiknya belum tersentuh secara memadai. Kajian ini menyoroti bagaimana wacana administrative rationalism, sebagaimana dirumuskan oleh Dryzek, mendominasi cara berpikir birokrasi Kota Bandung dalam menyusun kebijakan persampahan, sekaligus menelusuri peran dinamika politik, kapasitas kelembagaan, dan hambatan struktural yang membuat krisis ini terus berulang. Melalui studi literatur dengan pendekatan analisis wacana dan perspektif institusional, kajian ini menelaah dokumen kebijakan resmi serta literatur akademik terkait tata kelola sampah perkotaan. Hasil kajian memperlihatkan bahwa penanganan sampah di Bandung masih mengandalkan langkah teknis jangka pendek, seperti penambahan armada pengangkut dan perluasan kapasitas TPA, tanpa diimbangi penguatan dimensi sosial dan pelibatan warga secara substantif. Minimnya integrasi kebijakan, koordinasi lintas aktor yang lemah, serta kapasitas kelembagaan yang terbatas turut memperparah stagnasi ini. Kajian ini merekomendasikan pergeseran paradigma dari pendekatan teknokratis menuju model yang lebih partisipatif, kolaboratif, dan berorientasi keadilan lingkungan, agar penanganan sampah tidak lagi bersifat responsif-sementara, melainkan mampu menyelesaikan persoalan secara struktural dan berkelanjutan. Kata kunci: Tata kelola sampah; Rasionalisme administratif; Pengelolaan sampah perkotaan; Perspektif kelembagaan; Bandung

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Jurnal Wacana Sarjana
Published
2026-11-13
DOI
https://doi.org/10.17576/jws.v10i3.758
Primary Topic
Waste Management and Recycling
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Politics of Waste: A Critique of Bandung City Government’s Approach to Waste Governance

Mustabsyirotul Ummah Mustofa, Aldian Farobby, Muhammad Fathan Mubiinan, Alfano Padmasurya Noel Susilo et al.
2 links
Jurnal Wacana Sarjana
Waste Management and Recycling
article

Politics of Waste: A Critique of Bandung City Government’s Approach to Waste Governance

Mustabsyirotul Ummah Mustofa, Aldian Farobby, Muhammad Fathan Mubiinan, Alfano Padmasurya Noel Susilo, Aghnya Fauziah
article en

Abstract

ABSTRACT Bandung's chronic waste problem illustrates that urban environmental governance is shaped as much by bureaucratic worldview as by material capacity. Daily waste output of roughly 1,500 to 1,700 tonnes continues to be met with administrative fixes and engineering responses, leaving the deeper socio-political drivers of the crisis largely unaddressed. Drawing on Dryzek's notion of administrative rationalism, this paper investigates how a technocratic mode of reasoning has come to dominate the Bandung City Government's waste policymaking, and considers the political, institutional, and structural conditions that sustain a recurring cycle of crisis. The study relies on a qualitative literature review combined with discourse analysis and an institutional lens, examining official policy documents alongside scholarly work on urban solid-waste governance. Findings show that the city's response continues to privilege short-horizon technical fixes, among them fleet expansion and landfill enlargement, while social dimensions, behavioural change, and genuine citizen involvement remain secondary concerns. Fragmented coordination among agencies, weak policy integration, and constrained institutional capacity compound this stagnation. The paper argues for a discursive shift away from top-down technocracy toward a more deliberative, participatory, and collaborative governance model, one capable of moving waste policy beyond reactive crisis management toward a structurally grounded and sustainable resolution. Keywords: Waste governance; Administrative rationalism; Urban solid-waste management; Institutional perspective; Bandung ABSTRAK Krisis persampahan di Kota Bandung menjadi bukti bahwa persoalan lingkungan perkotaan bukan semata perkara keterbatasan sarana dan prasarana, melainkan juga produk dari cara pemerintah memaknai dan merumuskan masalah tersebut. Dengan volume timbulan harian yang berkisar antara 1.500 hingga 1.700 ton, kebijakan yang diambil pemerintah kota masih berkutat pada penyelesaian administratif dan rekayasa teknis, sehingga akar persoalan sosial-politiknya belum tersentuh secara memadai. Kajian ini menyoroti bagaimana wacana administrative rationalism, sebagaimana dirumuskan oleh Dryzek, mendominasi cara berpikir birokrasi Kota Bandung dalam menyusun kebijakan persampahan, sekaligus menelusuri peran dinamika politik, kapasitas kelembagaan, dan hambatan struktural yang membuat krisis ini terus berulang. Melalui studi literatur dengan pendekatan analisis wacana dan perspektif institusional, kajian ini menelaah dokumen kebijakan resmi serta literatur akademik terkait tata kelola sampah perkotaan. Hasil kajian memperlihatkan bahwa penanganan sampah di Bandung masih mengandalkan langkah teknis jangka pendek, seperti penambahan armada pengangkut dan perluasan kapasitas TPA, tanpa diimbangi penguatan dimensi sosial dan pelibatan warga secara substantif. Minimnya integrasi kebijakan, koordinasi lintas aktor yang lemah, serta kapasitas kelembagaan yang terbatas turut memperparah stagnasi ini. Kajian ini merekomendasikan pergeseran paradigma dari pendekatan teknokratis menuju model yang lebih partisipatif, kolaboratif, dan berorientasi keadilan lingkungan, agar penanganan sampah tidak lagi bersifat responsif-sementara, melainkan mampu menyelesaikan persoalan secara struktural dan berkelanjutan. Kata kunci: Tata kelola sampah; Rasionalisme administratif; Pengelolaan sampah perkotaan; Perspektif kelembagaan; Bandung

Jurnal Wacana SarjanaVol. 10(3)
Sustainable cities and communities, Responsible consumption and production, Peace, justice, and strong institutions
Waste Management and Recycling
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon