Urban-rural residence as the dominant source of inequality in the effectiveness of China's multi-tiered medical security system: an individual-level concentration index decomposition of CHARLS, 2011-2020

Abstract Background China has built a multi-tiered medical security system to protect its rapidly ageing population from medical costs, but the evaluations available rest on provincial indicators. Aggregates of that kind cannot show how protection is distributed among individuals. We therefore measured the effectiveness of the system for middle-aged and older Chinese adults and traced where the inequality in it originates. Methods We used five waves of the China Health and Retirement Longitudinal Study (2011–2020), comprising 93953 person-wave observations on 25390 respondents aged 45 and above. We constructed an individual-level index of multi-tiered medical security effectiveness from 11 indicators covering four dimensions, namely adequacy, equity, synergy and safety. Weights combined the Analytic Hierarchy Process with the entropy weight method. We measured inequality in the index with the concentration index, ranked by household consumption per capita, and decomposed it by the Wagstaff method into the contributions of urban-rural residence, education, macro-region and other determinants. We estimated determinants by pooled and two-way fixed-effects models, with standard errors clustered at the individual level. Results Effectiveness rose from 27.52 in 2011 to 28.79 in 2020. Safety scored highest throughout, at 0.89 or above. Adequacy was intermediate, at 0.24–0.27. Equity (0.12–0.13) and synergy (0.09–0.11) remained low. Synergy grew fastest (17.2%) and equity slowest (3.8%). Inequality was pro-rich in every wave, and the concentration index rose from 0.020 in 2011 to 0.0240 in 2020. Urban-rural residence contributed 29.1% of the pooled concentration index and education 16.4%, whereas macro-region contributed − 0.1%. Urban residents scored 3.02 to 4.29 points above rural residents. Household consumption per capita was positively associated with effectiveness in urban and eastern subsamples, but not in rural ones. Conclusions Inequality in the effectiveness of multi-tiered medical security among middle-aged and older Chinese adults is an urban-rural and individual phenomenon, not a regional one. Narrowing it calls for urban-rural equalisation and stronger supplementary and floor protection, not reallocation across regions. The finding also carries a general lesson for health equity measurement. Jurisdictional aggregates average away the within-jurisdiction variation that dominates at the individual level.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Research Square
Published
2026-11-13
DOI
https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11483094/v1
Primary Topic
Healthcare Systems and Reforms
Type
preprint

Funders

Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Urban-rural residence as the dominant source of inequality in the effectiveness of China's multi-tiered medical security system: an individual-level concentration index decomposition of CHARLS, 2011-2020

Yilong Wang, Aihong He, Yuxuan Wang
Research Square
Healthcare Systems and Reforms
preprint

Urban-rural residence as the dominant source of inequality in the effectiveness of China's multi-tiered medical security system: an individual-level concentration index decomposition of CHARLS, 2011-2020

Yilong Wang, Aihong He, Yuxuan Wang
preprint en

Abstract

Abstract Background China has built a multi-tiered medical security system to protect its rapidly ageing population from medical costs, but the evaluations available rest on provincial indicators. Aggregates of that kind cannot show how protection is distributed among individuals. We therefore measured the effectiveness of the system for middle-aged and older Chinese adults and traced where the inequality in it originates. Methods We used five waves of the China Health and Retirement Longitudinal Study (2011–2020), comprising 93953 person-wave observations on 25390 respondents aged 45 and above. We constructed an individual-level index of multi-tiered medical security effectiveness from 11 indicators covering four dimensions, namely adequacy, equity, synergy and safety. Weights combined the Analytic Hierarchy Process with the entropy weight method. We measured inequality in the index with the concentration index, ranked by household consumption per capita, and decomposed it by the Wagstaff method into the contributions of urban-rural residence, education, macro-region and other determinants. We estimated determinants by pooled and two-way fixed-effects models, with standard errors clustered at the individual level. Results Effectiveness rose from 27.52 in 2011 to 28.79 in 2020. Safety scored highest throughout, at 0.89 or above. Adequacy was intermediate, at 0.24–0.27. Equity (0.12–0.13) and synergy (0.09–0.11) remained low. Synergy grew fastest (17.2%) and equity slowest (3.8%). Inequality was pro-rich in every wave, and the concentration index rose from 0.020 in 2011 to 0.0240 in 2020. Urban-rural residence contributed 29.1% of the pooled concentration index and education 16.4%, whereas macro-region contributed − 0.1%. Urban residents scored 3.02 to 4.29 points above rural residents. Household consumption per capita was positively associated with effectiveness in urban and eastern subsamples, but not in rural ones. Conclusions Inequality in the effectiveness of multi-tiered medical security among middle-aged and older Chinese adults is an urban-rural and individual phenomenon, not a regional one. Narrowing it calls for urban-rural equalisation and stronger supplementary and floor protection, not reallocation across regions. The finding also carries a general lesson for health equity measurement. Jurisdictional aggregates average away the within-jurisdiction variation that dominates at the individual level.

Research Square
Northwest Minzu University (CN), Lanzhou Bowen College of Science and Technology (CN)
Peking University, Northwest Minzu University, Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities
Reduced inequalities, Good health and well-being, No poverty
Healthcare Systems and Reforms
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon