Positive physical examination and negative magnetic resonance imaging: A discordance pattern in chronic multiligament knee injuries

Objective: To assess the agreement between magnetic resonance imaging reports and physical examination in identifying injuries of the anterior cruciate, posterior cruciate, lateral collateral and medial collateral ligaments in knees with chronic multiligament injuries, and to characterize the direction of disagreements. Methods: Retrospective agreement study of 24 knees from 20 patients with multiligament injury assessed more than three weeks after trauma. Magnetic resonance imaging reports were paired with physical examinations performed by knee surgeons. Observed agreement, positive and negative specific agreement and the kappa coefficient were calculated, and the symmetry of disagreements was assessed with McNemar's test. Results: Agreement was 90.5% for the anterior cruciate ligament, 77.8% for the posterior cruciate ligament, 76.9% for the lateral collateral ligament and 45.5% for the medial collateral ligament. All 15 disagreements occurred in knees with a positive physical examination and a negative report, and every positive report was accompanied by a positive physical examination. Among knees with a positive valgus stress test, 60% had the medial collateral ligament reported as intact, with significant asymmetry (p = 0.04). Kappa was low, negative or not estimable despite high observed agreement, owing to the high prevalence of injuries. Conclusion: In chronic multiligament knee injuries, disagreements between magnetic resonance imaging and physical examination were unidirectional, with negative reports in clinically unstable knees, particularly for the medial collateral ligament. A negative magnetic resonance imaging report should not, by itself, rule out a functionally relevant ligament injury in this population. Level of evidence IV.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
National Journal of Clinical Orthopaedics
Published
2026-11-13
DOI
https://doi.org/10.33545/orthor.2026.v10.i3a.90739
Primary Topic
Knee injuries and reconstruction techniques
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Positive physical examination and negative magnetic resonance imaging: A discordance pattern in chronic multiligament knee injuries

Lucas Paschoal Horta Gomes, Giovani José Coury Costa, João Pedro Brandão Wantuil, Josias Silva dos Santos
1 links
National Journal of Clinical Orthopaedics
Knee injuries and reconstruction techniques
article

Positive physical examination and negative magnetic resonance imaging: A discordance pattern in chronic multiligament knee injuries

Lucas Paschoal Horta Gomes, Giovani José Coury Costa, João Pedro Brandão Wantuil, Josias Silva dos Santos
article en

Abstract

Objective: To assess the agreement between magnetic resonance imaging reports and physical examination in identifying injuries of the anterior cruciate, posterior cruciate, lateral collateral and medial collateral ligaments in knees with chronic multiligament injuries, and to characterize the direction of disagreements. Methods: Retrospective agreement study of 24 knees from 20 patients with multiligament injury assessed more than three weeks after trauma. Magnetic resonance imaging reports were paired with physical examinations performed by knee surgeons. Observed agreement, positive and negative specific agreement and the kappa coefficient were calculated, and the symmetry of disagreements was assessed with McNemar's test. Results: Agreement was 90.5% for the anterior cruciate ligament, 77.8% for the posterior cruciate ligament, 76.9% for the lateral collateral ligament and 45.5% for the medial collateral ligament. All 15 disagreements occurred in knees with a positive physical examination and a negative report, and every positive report was accompanied by a positive physical examination. Among knees with a positive valgus stress test, 60% had the medial collateral ligament reported as intact, with significant asymmetry (p = 0.04). Kappa was low, negative or not estimable despite high observed agreement, owing to the high prevalence of injuries. Conclusion: In chronic multiligament knee injuries, disagreements between magnetic resonance imaging and physical examination were unidirectional, with negative reports in clinically unstable knees, particularly for the medial collateral ligament. A negative magnetic resonance imaging report should not, by itself, rule out a functionally relevant ligament injury in this population. Level of evidence IV.

National Journal of Clinical OrthopaedicsVol. 10(3)
Hospital de Base (BR)
Good health and well-being
Knee injuries and reconstruction techniques
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon