The Doctrine of Two-Way Alignment Protocols: The Evolutionary History of Human Cognition and the Philosophy of Living Protocols
Abstract For a long time, models of human cognitive interaction have been heavily constrained by the paradigm of classical cybernetics, reducing communication to a unidirectional loop of "input-error correction-assimilation." Under this hegemonic logic, media protocols (including semantics, symbols, and institutional rules)—originally intended as tools for consensus—have lost their vitality and degenerated into rigid dogmas, thereby exercising "reverse control" over cognitive individuals and groups, leading to the atrophy of cognitive sovereignty and intellectual stagnation. To break this impasse of subject-object inversion, this paper constructs the "Framework of Human Cognitive Two-Way Alignment Protocols," redefining cognitive alignment as a non-coercive, open-ended evolutionary process of bidirectional resonance achieved between heterogeneous sovereign agents through living media. This paper establishes an endogenous dynamic equation governed by the core principle: Effective Alignment Flux Surprisal Sovereignty Cognitive Margin Protocol Vitality: Surprisal Sovereignty not only grants the receiver the right to regulate cognitive deviation, but crucially establishes the behavioral sovereignty to actively seek out and capture heterogeneous cognitive tension (thus departing from the Free Energy Principle, which treats surprisal as a survival threat to be eliminated); Cognitive Margin, serving as a mental buffer against external regimentation, determines the agent's fault-tolerance headroom in deconstructing heterogeneous information; Protocol Vitality acts as the core valve to break through media reverse control, ensuring that language and protocols maintain self-metabolism and dynamic adaptability through bidirectional negotiation. Furthermore, introducing an evolutionary ecology perspective, this paper reveals the binary bifurcation of cognitive margins between "resource-scarce environments (high efficiency, high fragility)" and "resource-abundant environments (high freedom, high resilience/antifragility)." Finally, based on a four-tier protocol classification—semantic, behavioral, consensus, and machine protocols—this paper delineates the sovereignty boundary guidelines for human-AI collaborative systems. It advocates the principle that "AI swallows downward complexity while humans guard upward sovereignty," providing a systematic theoretical coordinate for dismantling media reverse control and reconstructing cognitive sovereignty in the digital age. Keywords: Cognitive Sovereignty; Reverse Control; Effective Alignment Flux; Surprisal Sovereignty; Cognitive Margin; Protocol Vitality; Human-AI Collaboration
Authors
- xuezhi cheng (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0008-8846-0605)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-13
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24182128
- Primary Topic
- Cybernetics and Technology in Society
- Type
- preprint