Bentonite Waterstops vs. PVC Waterstops: Advantages, Applications, and Construction Joint Waterproofing Practices in Russia
Bentonite Waterstops vs. PVC Waterstops: Advantages, Applications, and Construction Joint Waterproofing Practices in Russia Author: Sergey A. SharapovVice-President, Union of Project Designers of Russia Abstract The selection of appropriate waterproofing systems for construction joints in reinforced concrete structures is a critical factor affecting structural durability, watertightness, construction efficiency, and long-term maintenance costs. This article provides a comparative engineering analysis of bentonite-based hydrophilic waterstops and conventional PVC waterstops, with particular emphasis on their respective applications, installation technologies, performance characteristics, and suitability for construction in cold climates. Special attention is given to the advantages of bentonite waterstop strips, also known as bentonite swelling tapes, hydroactive sealing cords, and water-swellable joint sealing profiles. Unlike conventional PVC waterstops, which function as embedded physical barriers, bentonite-based waterstops expand upon contact with water, creating sealing pressure within confined construction joints and helping to fill minor irregularities and voids at concrete interfaces. Their installation generally does not require thermal welding, which can simplify construction operations, particularly during winter concreting. The article examines a distinctive contradiction in Russian construction practice. Despite the country's prolonged periods of freezing temperatures, PVC waterstops have remained a widely used solution for waterproofing construction joints. Thermal welding of PVC profiles under low-temperature conditions may require additional protective enclosures, controlled working temperatures, specialized equipment, and qualified personnel. These requirements can increase installation complexity and labor costs. Bentonite waterstops can offer important technological advantages under such conditions, provided that manufacturer-specific installation requirements are satisfied. The analysis identifies several factors that may have contributed to the historically limited adoption of bentonite waterstops in Russia, including established engineering practices, uneven development of cost-estimating standards, insufficient availability of standardized construction details, and the previous absence of dedicated national standards for hydroactive bentonite sealing products. Particular attention is paid to the introduction of Russian national standards GOST R 72277-2025 and GOST R 72278-2025, which establish a more clearly defined technical and regulatory framework for hydroactive waterstop products. Another significant issue addressed in the article is the insufficient coordination between design documentation, working drawings, and construction method statements, including the Russian Project for the Production of Works (PPR). Because the final location and length of certain construction joints may depend on the actual concreting sequence, their waterproofing requirements are not always adequately established at the design stage. The article also examines the risks associated with relying exclusively on external membrane waterproofing. Mechanical damage during backfilling, construction operations, or subsequent service may compromise the external waterproofing barrier. Independent sealing of construction joints can therefore provide an additional level of protection against water ingress. Drawing on international engineering practices, manufacturers' technical documentation, and developments in the Russian construction industry, the article proposes a more systematic approach to selecting construction joint waterproofing technologies. It concludes that bentonite-based waterstops deserve broader consideration for suitable non-moving construction joints, especially in cold-climate construction, while PVC waterstops retain important applications in expansion and movement joints. The choice between these systems should be based on engineering requirements, verified material properties, installation conditions, and lifecycle cost considerations rather than established design habits alone. Keywords Bentonite waterstop; PVC waterstop; bentonite swelling strip; hydrophilic waterstop; construction joint waterproofing; concrete cold joints; water-swellable sealing tape; bentonite waterstop cord; reinforced concrete waterproofing; construction joint sealing; winter concreting; cold weather construction; underground waterproofing; basement waterproofing; waterstop installation; PVC waterstop welding; Russian construction standards; GOST R 72278-2025; construction waterproofing technology; waterproofing design. SEO Meta Title Bentonite vs PVC Waterstops: Benefits and Applications in Concrete Construction SEO Meta Description Engineering comparison of bentonite and PVC waterstops: construction joint sealing, winter installation, waterproofing reliability and Russian standards.
Authors
- Sergey Sharapov
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-13
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24189438
- Primary Topic
- Civil and Structural Engineering Research
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00