Governed Hybrid Agency: A Critical Evidence Map of Cognitive Architectures for Foundation-Model Agents

Background. Cognitive architectures specify the persistent memories, representations, learning processes, and control loops that allow an artificial agent to remain coherent across tasks and time. Foundation models provide broad generative competence, but do not by themselves ensure grounded action, reliable long-horizon memory, calibrated uncertainty, execution monitoring, or accountable learning. Objectives. This critical integrative review examines how cognitive-architecture principles are being used to govern foundation-model agents. Taking the last comprehensive pre-foundation-model survey of cognitive architectures (Kotseruba & Tsotsos, first published online in 2018) as its historical baseline, it maps developments across twelve ability channels, identifies recurring integration patterns, and derives testable design and evaluation requirements. Methods. We combined a historical-theoretical synthesis with a focused, PRISMA-informed evidence map of English-language records indexed in Scopus and the Web of Science Core Collection, searched in July 2026 over the 2018–2026 window. Queries required terms for cognitive architectures or architecture-level cognitive systems, foundation or generative models, and governance-relevant mechanisms. The searches identified 1,173 records; after deduplication, rule-based filtering, and LLMassisted title-and-abstract assessment, 119 works were retained and examined in full text. Because the 660 candidate records were not all independently human-rescreened, the corpus is interpreted as a reproducible focused evidence map rather than an exhaustive systematic review. Results. All included works were published or available online in 2023–2026. Five recurring integration patterns were identified: foundation models used for knowledge or generative memory, language or multimodal interfaces, heuristic proposal or planning, rule or model bootstrapping, and bidirectional neuro-symbolic coupling. Across these patterns, a recurring design principle is to place foundation models inside persistent control loops that provide explicit state, provenanceaware memory, verification, metacognitive arbitration, execution monitoring, and recovery. Evaluation remains uneven, particularly for calibration, retention, transfer, long-horizon robustness, disturbance recovery, and reproducibility. Conclusions. We propose governed hybrid agency, an Architectural Governance Stack, typed interface contracts, and a risk-based evaluation scorecard. These are integrative, falsifiable comparison targets rather than a validated universal architecture, and their value should be tested through matched ablations, intervention-sensitive evaluation, and cross-domain replication. A worked example instantiates the framework as a modular requirements-engineering reasoning architecture.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Journal of Artificial Intelligence Research
Published
2026-11-13
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1613/jair.1.23727
Primary Topic
Psychiatry, Mental Health, Neuroscience
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Governed Hybrid Agency: A Critical Evidence Map of Cognitive Architectures for Foundation-Model Agents

Aistė Diržytė, Darius Sabaliauskas
3 links
Journal of Artificial Intelligence Research
Psychiatry, Mental Health, Neuroscience
article

Governed Hybrid Agency: A Critical Evidence Map of Cognitive Architectures for Foundation-Model Agents

Aistė Diržytė, Darius Sabaliauskas
article en

Abstract

Background. Cognitive architectures specify the persistent memories, representations, learning processes, and control loops that allow an artificial agent to remain coherent across tasks and time. Foundation models provide broad generative competence, but do not by themselves ensure grounded action, reliable long-horizon memory, calibrated uncertainty, execution monitoring, or accountable learning. Objectives. This critical integrative review examines how cognitive-architecture principles are being used to govern foundation-model agents. Taking the last comprehensive pre-foundation-model survey of cognitive architectures (Kotseruba & Tsotsos, first published online in 2018) as its historical baseline, it maps developments across twelve ability channels, identifies recurring integration patterns, and derives testable design and evaluation requirements. Methods. We combined a historical-theoretical synthesis with a focused, PRISMA-informed evidence map of English-language records indexed in Scopus and the Web of Science Core Collection, searched in July 2026 over the 2018–2026 window. Queries required terms for cognitive architectures or architecture-level cognitive systems, foundation or generative models, and governance-relevant mechanisms. The searches identified 1,173 records; after deduplication, rule-based filtering, and LLMassisted title-and-abstract assessment, 119 works were retained and examined in full text. Because the 660 candidate records were not all independently human-rescreened, the corpus is interpreted as a reproducible focused evidence map rather than an exhaustive systematic review. Results. All included works were published or available online in 2023–2026. Five recurring integration patterns were identified: foundation models used for knowledge or generative memory, language or multimodal interfaces, heuristic proposal or planning, rule or model bootstrapping, and bidirectional neuro-symbolic coupling. Across these patterns, a recurring design principle is to place foundation models inside persistent control loops that provide explicit state, provenanceaware memory, verification, metacognitive arbitration, execution monitoring, and recovery. Evaluation remains uneven, particularly for calibration, retention, transfer, long-horizon robustness, disturbance recovery, and reproducibility. Conclusions. We propose governed hybrid agency, an Architectural Governance Stack, typed interface contracts, and a risk-based evaluation scorecard. These are integrative, falsifiable comparison targets rather than a validated universal architecture, and their value should be tested through matched ablations, intervention-sensitive evaluation, and cross-domain replication. A worked example instantiates the framework as a modular requirements-engineering reasoning architecture.

Journal of Artificial Intelligence ResearchVol. 87
Mykolas Romeris University (LT), Vilnius Gediminas Technical University (LT), Vilnius University (LT)
Psychiatry, Mental Health, Neuroscience
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon