The Price of Speed: Bits per Doubling of Rate
A converter that runs at a net rate J must leave equilibrium, and the distance it must keep—the affinity 𝒜, measured in bits (units of kBT ln 2)—is the price of its speed. We ask how many bits each doubling of J costs, and turn the answer into predictions that numbers can refute. For a single tightly coupled cycle obeying local detailed balance, any rate curve J(𝒜) splits into an odd and an even part. If the odd part, log₂[J(𝒜)/|J(−𝒜)|], is a straight line through the origin, its slope 2θ − 1 gives the transfer coefficient θ, independent of the exchange rate k₀ and of any symmetric modulation of the rates; the even part gives a symmetric factor ks(𝒜). The price of a doubling is then 1/[θ + 1/(2𝒜 − 1) + d ln ks/da] bits: the middle term is universal and dominates near equilibrium; for constant ks (Butler–Volmer) each doubling far from equilibrium costs 1/θ bits. The fluctuation–dissipation relation at stall gives k₀ from noise alone. We computed the published potential-switching model of F₁-ATPase with its published parameters and obtain three numerical predictions: (1) within |a| ≤ 4 kBT on either side of stall the odd part is a straight line, θ varying by less than 0.01; (2) if allosterism is totally asymmetric (q = 0), θ rises from 0.46 at low ATP to 0.54 at saturation, and for the opposite extreme (q = 1) it falls from 0.64 to 0.54—the direction in which θ changes with ATP discriminates the asymmetry of allosterism; (3) the even part is ln(ks/k₀) = −a²/4λ with λ ≈ 12–15 kBT (17–22 bits), i.e. of Marcus type. The computation also shows that the allosteric asymmetry discussed in the literature (q) is not the asymmetry of the rate (θ): as q goes from 0 to 1, θ changes by only 0.18. The same odd–even test is posed for FₒF₁-ATP synthase (fixed reaction quotient, ΔpH varied). Every ingredient is known (local detailed balance, Butler–Volmer, Tafel and Marcus kinetics, the fluctuation–dissipation relation, the potential-switching model); what is new is the odd–even decomposition as a test free of k₀, the bits-per-doubling form, and the numerical predictions above. As a separate interval estimate, the thermodynamic H⁺/ATP of the bovine c₈ enzyme at equilibrium should lie in 2.2–3.2. The cross-domain readings in the appendices are background, not tests; no social forecast is made.
Authors
- Yunjing Chen (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0008-8147-5089)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-13
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24183924
- Primary Topic
- Advanced Thermodynamics and Statistical Mechanics
- Type
- preprint