Clinical Interchangeability of Total Corneal Astigmatism Prediction Methods: An Agreement Analysis

Purpose: To compare agreement between total corneal astigmatism (TCA) predictions from a deep learning (DL) model and those from the Barrett Toric Calculator (Barrett) and Abulafia–Koch (AK) formulas. Methods: In 100 eyes with corneal astigmatism, Pentacam HR imaging (Oculus Optikgeräte GmbH) was used to generate TCA predictions with the AK formula, Barrett formula, and a previously validated DL model. Agreement was assessed using Pearson and Spearman correlation, mean absolute error (MAE), root mean square error (RMSE), and Bland-Altman analysis. Clinical interchangeability was predefined as 95% limits of agreement within ±0.25 diopters (D) for magnitude and ±5 degrees for axis. Predictions were also decomposed into Cartesian X and Y vector components. Results: The AK and Barrett formulas demonstrated near-perfect agreement for both magnitude ( r = 0.99; MAE: 0.070 D, RMSE: 0.11 D) and axis ( r = 1.00; MAE: 1.11°, RMSE: 1.68°), with 95% limits of agreement both within the interchangeability thresholds. Compared with both conventional methods, the DL model showed larger systematic differences. Compared with the Barrett formula, magnitude agreement was r = 0.92 (MAE: 0.24 D; RMSE: 0.27 D), and axis agreement was r = 1.00 (MAE: 4.71 degrees). Similar findings were observed versus the AK formula (magnitude r = 0.94, MAE: 0.20 D; axis MAE: 4.92°). The DL model consistently underestimated X-components relative to both traditional methods (RMSE: 0.28 to 0.31 D), whereas Y-component agreement was excellent across all pairs (RMSE ⩽ 0.05 D). DL axis differences followed a sinusoidal pattern with astigmatism orientation ( R 2 = 0.84 to 0.87), peaking at oblique meridians. Conclusions: The AK and Barrett formulas are clinically interchangeable for TCA prediction, with limits of agreement falling entirely within established toric intraocular lens planning thresholds. The DL model exhibits systematic, yet consistent deviations from both traditional methods that demonstrate lack of interchangeability. Prospective studies comparing postoperative refractive outcomes for each method are required to determine whether the DL model's deviations represent superior predictive performance.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Journal of Refractive Surgery
Published
2026-11-12
DOI
https://doi.org/10.3928/1081597x-20260903-04
Primary Topic
Intraocular Surgery and Lenses
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Clinical Interchangeability of Total Corneal Astigmatism Prediction Methods: An Agreement Analysis

Yoomin Lee, Avi A. Wallerstein, Mathieu Gauvin, Jason Fink et al.
Journal of Refractive Surgery
Intraocular Surgery and Lenses
article

Clinical Interchangeability of Total Corneal Astigmatism Prediction Methods: An Agreement Analysis

Yoomin Lee, Avi A. Wallerstein, Mathieu Gauvin, Jason Fink, Chirag Shah, Sapna Shah
article en

Abstract

Purpose: To compare agreement between total corneal astigmatism (TCA) predictions from a deep learning (DL) model and those from the Barrett Toric Calculator (Barrett) and Abulafia–Koch (AK) formulas. Methods: In 100 eyes with corneal astigmatism, Pentacam HR imaging (Oculus Optikgeräte GmbH) was used to generate TCA predictions with the AK formula, Barrett formula, and a previously validated DL model. Agreement was assessed using Pearson and Spearman correlation, mean absolute error (MAE), root mean square error (RMSE), and Bland-Altman analysis. Clinical interchangeability was predefined as 95% limits of agreement within ±0.25 diopters (D) for magnitude and ±5 degrees for axis. Predictions were also decomposed into Cartesian X and Y vector components. Results: The AK and Barrett formulas demonstrated near-perfect agreement for both magnitude ( r = 0.99; MAE: 0.070 D, RMSE: 0.11 D) and axis ( r = 1.00; MAE: 1.11°, RMSE: 1.68°), with 95% limits of agreement both within the interchangeability thresholds. Compared with both conventional methods, the DL model showed larger systematic differences. Compared with the Barrett formula, magnitude agreement was r = 0.92 (MAE: 0.24 D; RMSE: 0.27 D), and axis agreement was r = 1.00 (MAE: 4.71 degrees). Similar findings were observed versus the AK formula (magnitude r = 0.94, MAE: 0.20 D; axis MAE: 4.92°). The DL model consistently underestimated X-components relative to both traditional methods (RMSE: 0.28 to 0.31 D), whereas Y-component agreement was excellent across all pairs (RMSE ⩽ 0.05 D). DL axis differences followed a sinusoidal pattern with astigmatism orientation ( R 2 = 0.84 to 0.87), peaking at oblique meridians. Conclusions: The AK and Barrett formulas are clinically interchangeable for TCA prediction, with limits of agreement falling entirely within established toric intraocular lens planning thresholds. The DL model exhibits systematic, yet consistent deviations from both traditional methods that demonstrate lack of interchangeability. Prospective studies comparing postoperative refractive outcomes for each method are required to determine whether the DL model's deviations represent superior predictive performance.

Journal of Refractive Surgery
Philadelphia College of Osteopathic Medicine (US), Society of Interventional Radiology (US), McGill University (CA)
Good health and well-being
Intraocular Surgery and Lenses
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon