Community cultural wealth in general chemistry: how students from historically marginalized groups leverage their assets in first-year chemistry

General chemistry is widely recognized as a “gatekeeper” course that disproportionately impacts students from historically marginalized groups (HMGs), contributing to their underrepresentation in STEM. While much discourse focuses on deficits, limited research examines the strengths these students bring to chemistry classrooms. This qualitative study employed the community cultural wealth (CCW) framework to examine what forms of cultural capital 28 students from HMGs drew upon to navigate a first-semester general chemistry course at an R1 university, how this varied by academic outcome (High pass, N = 9; Pass, N = 11; unsuccessful, N = 8), and which course structures supported students in leveraging their capital. Nearly all participants utilized aspirational (96%), social (96%), and navigational capital (93%), with familial (68%) and resistant capital (29%) also widely reported. Spiritual (4%) and linguistic capital (0%) were rarely or never reported. Determination was reported by 39% of participants. We also identify perseverance, an emergent construct not previously captured in CCW literature, reported by 36%. Capital utilization varied by performance cohort, challenging deficit narratives: unsuccessful students reported different configurations of capital, not less, including disproportionately high familial (100%), perseverance (63%), and resistant capital (38%). Office hours and peer interactions primarily supported navigational and social capital; remaining capitals were largely unaddressed. Recognizing cultural wealth can transform chemistry classrooms from gatekeeping spaces into asset-affirming environments. Implications include embedding post-exam reflection to build on perseverance, redesigning course touchpoints to recognize capitals unaddressed by formal design, and providing differentiated, cohort-responsive support that honors distinct capital configurations across performance levels.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Chemistry Education Research and Practice
Published
2026-11-12
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1039/d6rp00332j
Primary Topic
Higher Education Research Studies
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Community cultural wealth in general chemistry: how students from historically marginalized groups leverage their assets in first-year chemistry

Caroline Z. Muteti, Klaudja Caushi, Binyomin Abrams, Nadja Jacimovic et al.
Chemistry Education Research and Practice
Higher Education Research Studies
article

Community cultural wealth in general chemistry: how students from historically marginalized groups leverage their assets in first-year chemistry

Caroline Z. Muteti, Klaudja Caushi, Binyomin Abrams, Nadja Jacimovic, Paul Fertig, Alex Griffiths
article en

Abstract

General chemistry is widely recognized as a “gatekeeper” course that disproportionately impacts students from historically marginalized groups (HMGs), contributing to their underrepresentation in STEM. While much discourse focuses on deficits, limited research examines the strengths these students bring to chemistry classrooms. This qualitative study employed the community cultural wealth (CCW) framework to examine what forms of cultural capital 28 students from HMGs drew upon to navigate a first-semester general chemistry course at an R1 university, how this varied by academic outcome (High pass, N = 9; Pass, N = 11; unsuccessful, N = 8), and which course structures supported students in leveraging their capital. Nearly all participants utilized aspirational (96%), social (96%), and navigational capital (93%), with familial (68%) and resistant capital (29%) also widely reported. Spiritual (4%) and linguistic capital (0%) were rarely or never reported. Determination was reported by 39% of participants. We also identify perseverance, an emergent construct not previously captured in CCW literature, reported by 36%. Capital utilization varied by performance cohort, challenging deficit narratives: unsuccessful students reported different configurations of capital, not less, including disproportionately high familial (100%), perseverance (63%), and resistant capital (38%). Office hours and peer interactions primarily supported navigational and social capital; remaining capitals were largely unaddressed. Recognizing cultural wealth can transform chemistry classrooms from gatekeeping spaces into asset-affirming environments. Implications include embedding post-exam reflection to build on perseverance, redesigning course touchpoints to recognize capitals unaddressed by formal design, and providing differentiated, cohort-responsive support that honors distinct capital configurations across performance levels.

Chemistry Education Research and Practice
Boston University (US), University of Massachusetts Boston (US), Wheelock College (US)
Reduced inequalities, Quality education
Higher Education Research Studies
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon