Integrating Diagnostic and Management Reasoning in Medical Genetics Education: A Two-Session Database-Driven and Simulation-Based Intervention for Pre-Clinical Students

Abstract Background Clinical reasoning constitutes a core competency for health professions trainees. However, traditional medical genetics instruction faces three major challenges: disconnection from real clinical scenarios, passive student engagement, and insufficient translation of basic science knowledge into clinical reasoning practice. This study evaluated a two-session intervention with distinct but interconnected purposes—diagnostic reasoning in Session 1 and management reasoning in Session 2—to develop both dimensions within a coherent, learner-centered framework. Methods A mixed-methods study recruited 30 pre-clinical Chinese medical undergraduates. Session 1 adopted a dual-teacher model with a 1,152-case chromosomal abnormality database for group data inquiry to train diagnostic reasoning. Session 2 delivered simulated genetic counseling with real-time bullet-screen comments to develop management reasoning. Questionnaires, group assignments, counseling scripts, and end-of-course examination scores were analyzed. Results All six groups identified clinically significant karyotype patterns not found in standard textbooks. Two groups found distributions deviating substantially from textbook expectations, triggering cognitive conflict and shifting students from passive “answer-seeking” to active “questioning-verifying” reasoning. Discussion board questions progressed from factual recall to analysis (38.9%) and evaluation (22.2%). Diagnostic thinking from Session 1 was applied in Session 2 counseling scripts. In an exploratory comparison with a historical cohort taught by the same instructors using the same assessment, the intervention group scored significantly higher (91.03 ± 4.89 vs 85.25 ± 7.97; t(58) = 3.38, p = 0.0013; Cohen’s d = 0.87), and the proportion scoring ≥ 90 increased from 43.3% to 76.7% (χ² = 5.33, p = 0.021). Conclusions The progressive two-stage intervention provides a replicable curriculum framework that integrates diagnostic and management reasoning within a single coherent instructional arc. Students demonstrated a shift from passive answer-seeking to active questioning-verifying reasoning, and preliminary evidence from historical cohort comparison suggests measurable gains in examination performance on content directly aligned with the intervention. The model is particularly relevant in the current era, where fostering independent clinical thinking and patient-centered communication has become an urgent educational priority.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Research Square
Published
2026-11-12
DOI
https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-10510265/v1
Primary Topic
Clinical Reasoning and Diagnostic Skills
Type
preprint

Funders

Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Integrating Diagnostic and Management Reasoning in Medical Genetics Education: A Two-Session Database-Driven and Simulation-Based Intervention for Pre-Clinical Students

Xin Jin, 金结媛, 方兴亮, Yan Zeng et al.
Research Square
Clinical Reasoning and Diagnostic Skills
preprint

Integrating Diagnostic and Management Reasoning in Medical Genetics Education: A Two-Session Database-Driven and Simulation-Based Intervention for Pre-Clinical Students

Xin Jin, 金结媛, 方兴亮, Yan Zeng, Wenlong Jin
preprint en

Abstract

Abstract Background Clinical reasoning constitutes a core competency for health professions trainees. However, traditional medical genetics instruction faces three major challenges: disconnection from real clinical scenarios, passive student engagement, and insufficient translation of basic science knowledge into clinical reasoning practice. This study evaluated a two-session intervention with distinct but interconnected purposes—diagnostic reasoning in Session 1 and management reasoning in Session 2—to develop both dimensions within a coherent, learner-centered framework. Methods A mixed-methods study recruited 30 pre-clinical Chinese medical undergraduates. Session 1 adopted a dual-teacher model with a 1,152-case chromosomal abnormality database for group data inquiry to train diagnostic reasoning. Session 2 delivered simulated genetic counseling with real-time bullet-screen comments to develop management reasoning. Questionnaires, group assignments, counseling scripts, and end-of-course examination scores were analyzed. Results All six groups identified clinically significant karyotype patterns not found in standard textbooks. Two groups found distributions deviating substantially from textbook expectations, triggering cognitive conflict and shifting students from passive “answer-seeking” to active “questioning-verifying” reasoning. Discussion board questions progressed from factual recall to analysis (38.9%) and evaluation (22.2%). Diagnostic thinking from Session 1 was applied in Session 2 counseling scripts. In an exploratory comparison with a historical cohort taught by the same instructors using the same assessment, the intervention group scored significantly higher (91.03 ± 4.89 vs 85.25 ± 7.97; t(58) = 3.38, p = 0.0013; Cohen’s d = 0.87), and the proportion scoring ≥ 90 increased from 43.3% to 76.7% (χ² = 5.33, p = 0.021). Conclusions The progressive two-stage intervention provides a replicable curriculum framework that integrates diagnostic and management reasoning within a single coherent instructional arc. Students demonstrated a shift from passive answer-seeking to active questioning-verifying reasoning, and preliminary evidence from historical cohort comparison suggests measurable gains in examination performance on content directly aligned with the intervention. The model is particularly relevant in the current era, where fostering independent clinical thinking and patient-centered communication has become an urgent educational priority.

Research Square
Shaoxing University (CN), Shaoxing City Women and Children Hospital (CN)
Shaoxing University
Quality education, Good health and well-being
Clinical Reasoning and Diagnostic Skills
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon