The Undecidable Domain and the Operationalization of Free Will: A Decision-Theoretic Philosophical Approach

The core presupposition of Savage-style decision theory is that the state space is given. However, in scenarios such as institutional change, technological paradigm shifts, and governance framework innovation, the relevant states are not given ex ante but are dynamically generated by the agent's commitments. This paper models such situations as an undecidable domain within a formal system, arguing that free will is the operation of suspending the truth-value of undecidable propositions, an operation that enables the subsequent generation of the state space. The framework demarcates the validity boundary of old theories through a degenerate-recurrence test and locks an incremental prediction within the 2026–2028 time window via the pre-registration protocol PR-2026-001. Even if the ontological identity claim is rejected, the operational-level degenerate recurrence and pre-registration mechanism retain independent epistemological value. The contribution of this paper lies in: stripping free will from metaphysical controversy and operationalizing it as a testable state-space generation mechanism within decision theory, while establishing connections with compatibilism, the agent-causal approach, conceptual engineering, and incommensurability arguments in the philosophy of science. Keywords: Undecidable Domain; Free Will; Decision Theory; Truth-Value Suspension; Pre-registration; Degenerate Recurrence 摘要:Savage式决策理论的核心预设是状态空间给定。但在制度变迁、技术范式转换与治理框架革新等场景中,相关状态并非事前给定,而由行动者的承诺动态生成。本文将此类情形建模为形式系统内的不可判定域,论证自由意志是在不可判定命题上悬断真值的操作,该悬断使后续状态空间得以生成。框架以退化复现检验标定旧理论的成立边界,并以预注册协议PR‑2026‑001将一条增量预测锁定于2026—2028时间窗。即使拒绝存在论同一主张,操作层的退化复现与预注册机制仍具独立认识论价值。本文的贡献在于:将自由意志从形而上学争议中剥离,操作化为决策理论内可检验的状态空间生成机制,并与兼容论、agent‑causal进路、概念工程及科学哲学中的不可通约性论证建立了对接。 关键词:不可判定域;自由意志;决策理论;真值悬断;预注册;退化复现

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-12
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24165187
Primary Topic
Free Will and Agency
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

The Undecidable Domain and the Operationalization of Free Will: A Decision-Theoretic Philosophical Approach

光 许
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Free Will and Agency
preprint

The Undecidable Domain and the Operationalization of Free Will: A Decision-Theoretic Philosophical Approach

光 许
preprint en

Abstract

The core presupposition of Savage-style decision theory is that the state space is given. However, in scenarios such as institutional change, technological paradigm shifts, and governance framework innovation, the relevant states are not given ex ante but are dynamically generated by the agent's commitments. This paper models such situations as an undecidable domain within a formal system, arguing that free will is the operation of suspending the truth-value of undecidable propositions, an operation that enables the subsequent generation of the state space. The framework demarcates the validity boundary of old theories through a degenerate-recurrence test and locks an incremental prediction within the 2026–2028 time window via the pre-registration protocol PR-2026-001. Even if the ontological identity claim is rejected, the operational-level degenerate recurrence and pre-registration mechanism retain independent epistemological value. The contribution of this paper lies in: stripping free will from metaphysical controversy and operationalizing it as a testable state-space generation mechanism within decision theory, while establishing connections with compatibilism, the agent-causal approach, conceptual engineering, and incommensurability arguments in the philosophy of science. Keywords: Undecidable Domain; Free Will; Decision Theory; Truth-Value Suspension; Pre-registration; Degenerate Recurrence 摘要:Savage式决策理论的核心预设是状态空间给定。但在制度变迁、技术范式转换与治理框架革新等场景中,相关状态并非事前给定,而由行动者的承诺动态生成。本文将此类情形建模为形式系统内的不可判定域,论证自由意志是在不可判定命题上悬断真值的操作,该悬断使后续状态空间得以生成。框架以退化复现检验标定旧理论的成立边界,并以预注册协议PR‑2026‑001将一条增量预测锁定于2026—2028时间窗。即使拒绝存在论同一主张,操作层的退化复现与预注册机制仍具独立认识论价值。本文的贡献在于:将自由意志从形而上学争议中剥离,操作化为决策理论内可检验的状态空间生成机制,并与兼容论、agent‑causal进路、概念工程及科学哲学中的不可通约性论证建立了对接。 关键词:不可判定域;自由意志;决策理论;真值悬断;预注册;退化复现

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Peace, justice, and strong institutions
Free Will and Agency
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon