Historical Evaluation of Integrated Project Control Early Warning Indicators in Four United States Transit Capital Projects
Abstract Major U.S. transit capital projects are monitored through cost and schedule measures that may not fully represent change, contractor and construction-interface pressures. This study retrospectively applied the frozen Integrated Project Controls and Risk Forecasting Framework (IPCRF), Version 1.2, to four U.S. transit capital projects with contrasting outcomes: NYCT ADA station improvements, Dulles Corridor Metrorail Phase 2, East Side Access/Grand Central Madison, and the Canarsie Tube/L Project Tunnel Rehabilitation as a favorable-outcome comparator. Twelve selected project-level historical observations were reconstructed from transit-agency and Federal Transit Administration records; Case 4 also contributed eight component-level contingency-stress observations. Additional monthly PMOC records for Dulles and East Side Access were examined in a reporting-period sensitivity analysis. NYCT Finish Slippage moved from Low to Critical after its completion forecast changed but before the original completion target. Dulles retained Low project-level EAC variance while Total Change Exposure remained High, alongside documented contractual milestone failures. East Side Access showed Elevated cost and conditional schedule classifications with access and interface constraints. Canarsie remained Low for Finish Slippage at both historical snapshots; seven component Contingency Stress observations were Low, and one was Watch, with none Elevated or above. Incomplete and uneven records prevented formal six-domain PDRS/FCS scoring. The findings support retrospective indicator-level reconstruction across contrasting outcomes, but do not establish specificity, false-positive performance or prospective predictive validity.
Authors
- Mohammed Adeyemi Yusuff
Institutions
- Northeastern University (US)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Research Square
- Published
- 2026-11-12
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11283302/v1
- Primary Topic
- Construction Project Management and Performance
- Type
- preprint