Polyphemus in the Cave and the Absence of Public Persuasion: An Institutional Analysis of Status-Demographic Codes from Early Joseon to Colonial and Post-Colonial Surveillance Enclosures
This study investigates a foundational void in the constitutional and legal history of the Korean peninsula: the structural non-existence of political persuasion. In comparative state formation, deliberative persuasion functioned not as moral benevolence, but as a formal transaction cost extorted by the material capacity of direct producers to execute systemic rupture—exemplified by Roman republican plebeian secessions. Across five centuries of the Joseon dynasty and its twentieth-century transformations, peninsular state power operated upon an inverse trajectory. The governed were never constituted as horizontal negotiating subjects possessing juridical standing; rather, they were regimentally quarantined within patriarchal units of production under centralized bureaucratic oversight. By examining the institutional continuity of status codes, colonial cadastral dispossession, the reception of Bismarckian-Meiji Pandectist jurisprudence in the 1958 Civil Code, and the permanent reproduction of extraordinary penal regimes, this monograph demonstrates that the post-colonial republic preserved and refined the coercive machinery of the inherited state apparatus. Rather than fulfilling an emancipated compact among co-legislating citizens, this historical development culminated in an unbroken bureaucratized enclosure. Perfected through the 1968 universal biometric registration system and managed by a credentialed technocratic caste, the contemporary state definitively fixed the direct producer where peninsular statecraft has always confined him: an administered asset, governed entirely without the procedural friction of persuasion.
Authors
- Hyun-nam Im (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0001-0477-755X)
Publication Details
- Journal
- SocArXiv (OSF Preprints)
- Published
- 2026-11-13
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.31235/osf.io/znpd2
- Primary Topic
- Korean Peninsula Historical and Political Studies
- Type
- preprint