The Persistence of the Unfinished State: Temporal Form in Beethoven’s Late String Quartets Opp. 131 and 132

This article proposes a new perspective on Beethoven’s late style by reconsidering musical form as a fundamentally temporal phenomenon. While previous scholarship has illuminated the formal innovations of Beethoven’s late string quartets through concepts such as motivic unity, cyclic integration, formal deformation, and processual form, these approaches have largely continued to treat form as an architectural organization of structural units. This study argues instead that Beethoven’s late quartets redefine form through the experience of musical time. Drawing on Carl Dahlhaus’s concept of processual form, Janet Schmalfeldt’s theory of becoming, and Jonathan Kramer’s writings on musical temporality, this article develops a theoretical framework based on three interrelated concepts: process, mediation, and the unfinished state. The unfinished state is defined not as the absence of formal closure but as a temporal condition in which completion remains structurally projected while experientially deferred. The argument is developed through comparative analyses of String Quartets Opp. 131 and 132. In Op. 131, the second and third movements function as mediating temporal fields that fragment, suspend, and redirect musical continuity rather than serving as merely subordinate or transitional movements. In Op. 132, the first and third movements reveal a complementary strategy in which thematic identity, cadential closure, and recapitulatory return emerge as ongoing processes of becoming rather than fixed structural events. Although realized through different compositional strategies, both quartets transform formal coherence from a spatial architecture into a dynamic experience of time. The article concludes that mediation and process constitute complementary models of temporal form, while the unfinished state represents a defining characteristic of Beethoven’s late style. More broadly, it suggests that formal analysis may profit from shifting its emphasis from completed structures to the temporal conditions through which musical meaning continuously emerges, unfolds, and remains open.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Journal of the Musicological Society of Korea
Published
2026-11-12
DOI
https://doi.org/10.16939/jmsk.2026.29.2.61
Primary Topic
Musicology and Musical Analysis
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

The Persistence of the Unfinished State: Temporal Form in Beethoven’s Late String Quartets Opp. 131 and 132

Moo Kyoung Song, The Musicological Society Of Korea, Sun Y Chung
Journal of the Musicological Society of Korea
Musicology and Musical Analysis
article

The Persistence of the Unfinished State: Temporal Form in Beethoven’s Late String Quartets Opp. 131 and 132

Moo Kyoung Song, The Musicological Society Of Korea, Sun Y Chung
article en

Abstract

This article proposes a new perspective on Beethoven’s late style by reconsidering musical form as a fundamentally temporal phenomenon. While previous scholarship has illuminated the formal innovations of Beethoven’s late string quartets through concepts such as motivic unity, cyclic integration, formal deformation, and processual form, these approaches have largely continued to treat form as an architectural organization of structural units. This study argues instead that Beethoven’s late quartets redefine form through the experience of musical time. Drawing on Carl Dahlhaus’s concept of processual form, Janet Schmalfeldt’s theory of becoming, and Jonathan Kramer’s writings on musical temporality, this article develops a theoretical framework based on three interrelated concepts: process, mediation, and the unfinished state. The unfinished state is defined not as the absence of formal closure but as a temporal condition in which completion remains structurally projected while experientially deferred. The argument is developed through comparative analyses of String Quartets Opp. 131 and 132. In Op. 131, the second and third movements function as mediating temporal fields that fragment, suspend, and redirect musical continuity rather than serving as merely subordinate or transitional movements. In Op. 132, the first and third movements reveal a complementary strategy in which thematic identity, cadential closure, and recapitulatory return emerge as ongoing processes of becoming rather than fixed structural events. Although realized through different compositional strategies, both quartets transform formal coherence from a spatial architecture into a dynamic experience of time. The article concludes that mediation and process constitute complementary models of temporal form, while the unfinished state represents a defining characteristic of Beethoven’s late style. More broadly, it suggests that formal analysis may profit from shifting its emphasis from completed structures to the temporal conditions through which musical meaning continuously emerges, unfolds, and remains open.

Journal of the Musicological Society of KoreaVol. 29(2)
Musicology and Musical Analysis
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon