Public Breaking-Temporality: How Institutional Facts are Generated — A Reconsideration of Searle and Schmitt
Searle's theory of institutional facts grounds the formula "X counts as Y in context C" in a pre-existing collective intentionality; Schmitt's decisionism attributes the creation of institutions to the sovereign's pure decision unconstrained by norms. While each captures a dimension of institutions—"coexistence recognition" and "decisive creation" respectively—both have theoretical blind spots. Building upon the ontological achievements of the preceding papers in this series, this paper proposes the concept of Public Breaking-Temporality: dispersed individual positings do not equate to institutions; only when they cross a coordination threshold and undergo a hierarchical leap does public grammatical reality and the institutional-public subject emerge, which cannot be fully reduced to the sum of individuals. In the public undecidable domain where old frameworks fail, public frameworks can be born prior to mature collective intentionality; collective intentionality is often a sedimented product after public breaking-temporality, rather than a precondition for institutional creation. Meanwhile, although public breaking-temporality contains a decisive element, decision alone cannot guarantee the substantive validity of institutions; it must undergo the test of existential guarantee at the public level. Public grammar likewise undergoes adaptation, reconstruction, and brittle fracture. This study is the fifth paper in this series of ontological research. Keywords: Public Breaking-Temporality; Institutional-Public Subject; Collective Intentionality; Searle; Schmitt; Undecidable Domain 摘要:塞尔的制度事实理论将“X在C中被我们视作Y”奠基于在先的集体意向性;施米特的决断论把制度创生归为主权者不受规范约束的纯粹决断。二者分别抓住制度的“共在承认”与“决断创设”两个维度,但都存在理论盲区。依托本系列前序存在论成果,本文提出公共破时性概念:分散的个体立定本身不等于制度,只有跨过协调门槛发生层级跃迁,才生成不可完全还原为个体总和的公共语法实在与制度‑公共主体。在旧框架失效的公共不可判定域,公共框架可以先于成熟的集体意向性而诞生,集体意向性往往是公共破时性之后的沉淀产物,而非制度创生的前置条件。同时,公共破时性虽包含决断要素,但决断不能单独保证制度的实质效力,必须经受公共层面的生存论担保检验;公共语法同样会经历调适、重构与脆性断裂。本研究是系列存在论研究第五篇。 关键词:公共破时性;制度‑公共主体;集体意向性;塞尔;施米特;不可判定域
Authors
- 光 许
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-12
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24164353
- Primary Topic
- Political Theology and Sovereignty
- Type
- preprint