Do teachers and students see the same teacher? Profile agreement on social-emotional and instructional skills and teacher retention
Social-emotional and instructional (SEI) skills of teachers are usually measured through self-report, yet students experience these skills daily and may see them differently. This study examined (1) how closely teachers’ self-ratings of SEI skills agree with their students’ ratings and (2) whether this agreement relates to teachers’ job satisfaction and turnover intentions. Flemish secondary school teachers (N = 137) and 1,944 of their students rated the same 37 behaviors on a too-little-too-much (TLTM) scale. Teachers saw themselves as closer to “just right” than students did (dz = −0.28), and agreement on individual dimensions was modest (r = .04–.48). Still, each teacher’s distinctive skill profile matched their own class’s view (mean r = .18) far better than a random class’s (r = .00, p < .001), and class-level student profiles were highly stable over three months (r = .57 own vs. −.01 other class). In exploratory analyses among the 74 teachers with job outcome data, those whose self-profile agreed more with their students’ view reported lower turnover intentions (β = −.43); this effect held across a series of robustness checks, including controls for self-rated professional commitment and job satisfaction. Students’ perceptions of misfit in connecting, reflective practice and flexibility were related to lower job satisfaction. Being “in tune” with students’ view of one’s teaching may be a resource for teacher retention, which supports the use of structured student feedback in professional development.
Authors
- Joyce Scheirlinckx (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5233-8773)
Institutions
- Ghent University (BE)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-12
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24173073
- Primary Topic
- Teacher Education and Leadership Studies
- Type
- preprint