A Dynamic Spatial Risk Map Model for Industrial Robots Integrating Robot Motion, Proximity, Safeguarding, and Worker Exposure

The risk level of an industrial robot can vary over time and space depending on robot position and speed, worker access and dwell, and the functional status of safeguarding devices. Conventional risk assessment methods, such as frequency–severity assessment and checklist-based assessment, are useful for hazard identification and prioritizing improvements; however, they have limitations in quantifying, at the grid level, where and when risk is concentrated during robot operation and how high-risk areas change. To address these limitations, this study proposes a dynamic spatial risk map model for visualizing relative risk over time and space in industrial robot workspaces. The model normalizes four factors—Risk Energy (RE), Distance Risk (RD), Protection Risk (RP), and Worker Exposure Risk (RH)—and applies AHP-derived weights in a multiplicative integrated risk index. Its main contribution is to integrate different risk factors into a single index while calculating grid and time-specific risk distributions, the maximum risk value, the maximum-risk grid, the time of maximum risk, and the proportion of high-risk areas, thereby enabling analysis of the spatial concentration and temporal variation of risk. The proposed model was applied to a reconstructed fatal industrial robot accident and a safeguarding-system improvement case. In the accident case, the maximum integrated risk index was 96.6155, the center of the maximum-risk grid was (2.125, 0.625) m, the time of occurrence was 23.17 s, and the Very High area ratio at that time was 15.87%. The maximum-risk grid showed a spatial pattern similar to the entrapment location described in the accident case, between the robot arm and the front column of the trimming machine. In the safeguarding-system improvement case, the maximum integrated risk indices were 88.61, 100.00, and 77.09 for the normal operation of the side photoelectric safeguarding device, the delay-error condition, and the condition with an additional ankle-level safeguarding device, respectively. Under the improved condition, in which an ankle-level device was added and the robot remained in standby when a worker was detected, the Very High area ratio was 0%. These results demonstrate that relative risk levels and high-risk areas can be quantitatively compared under different safeguarding conditions. Comparison with conventional frequency–severity assessment and Speed and Separation Monitoring (SSM) indicates that the proposed model may serve as a complementary tool rather than a replacement for existing methods. It adds temporal and spatial risk-distribution information to the hazard-improvement priorities and protective-separation-distance information provided by those methods. However, the risk index does not represent actual accident probability or calibrated injury severity, and some input data, including robot position and speed, were reconstructed from field investigation and statements by personnel involved. For application in industrial workplaces, actual operating data should therefore be obtained where feasible, and the results should be interpreted in light of the assumptions and limitations of the input data.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Applied Sciences
Published
2026-11-12
DOI
https://doi.org/10.3390/app162211232
Primary Topic
Occupational Health and Safety in Workplaces
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

A Dynamic Spatial Risk Map Model for Industrial Robots Integrating Robot Motion, Proximity, Safeguarding, and Worker Exposure

Shin Dong-Kil, Hyun-Wook Yeo
Applied Sciences
Occupational Health and Safety in Workplaces
article

A Dynamic Spatial Risk Map Model for Industrial Robots Integrating Robot Motion, Proximity, Safeguarding, and Worker Exposure

Shin Dong-Kil, Hyun-Wook Yeo
article en

Abstract

The risk level of an industrial robot can vary over time and space depending on robot position and speed, worker access and dwell, and the functional status of safeguarding devices. Conventional risk assessment methods, such as frequency–severity assessment and checklist-based assessment, are useful for hazard identification and prioritizing improvements; however, they have limitations in quantifying, at the grid level, where and when risk is concentrated during robot operation and how high-risk areas change. To address these limitations, this study proposes a dynamic spatial risk map model for visualizing relative risk over time and space in industrial robot workspaces. The model normalizes four factors—Risk Energy (RE), Distance Risk (RD), Protection Risk (RP), and Worker Exposure Risk (RH)—and applies AHP-derived weights in a multiplicative integrated risk index. Its main contribution is to integrate different risk factors into a single index while calculating grid and time-specific risk distributions, the maximum risk value, the maximum-risk grid, the time of maximum risk, and the proportion of high-risk areas, thereby enabling analysis of the spatial concentration and temporal variation of risk. The proposed model was applied to a reconstructed fatal industrial robot accident and a safeguarding-system improvement case. In the accident case, the maximum integrated risk index was 96.6155, the center of the maximum-risk grid was (2.125, 0.625) m, the time of occurrence was 23.17 s, and the Very High area ratio at that time was 15.87%. The maximum-risk grid showed a spatial pattern similar to the entrapment location described in the accident case, between the robot arm and the front column of the trimming machine. In the safeguarding-system improvement case, the maximum integrated risk indices were 88.61, 100.00, and 77.09 for the normal operation of the side photoelectric safeguarding device, the delay-error condition, and the condition with an additional ankle-level safeguarding device, respectively. Under the improved condition, in which an ankle-level device was added and the robot remained in standby when a worker was detected, the Very High area ratio was 0%. These results demonstrate that relative risk levels and high-risk areas can be quantitatively compared under different safeguarding conditions. Comparison with conventional frequency–severity assessment and Speed and Separation Monitoring (SSM) indicates that the proposed model may serve as a complementary tool rather than a replacement for existing methods. It adds temporal and spatial risk-distribution information to the hazard-improvement priorities and protective-separation-distance information provided by those methods. However, the risk index does not represent actual accident probability or calibrated injury severity, and some input data, including robot position and speed, were reconstructed from field investigation and statements by personnel involved. For application in industrial workplaces, actual operating data should therefore be obtained where feasible, and the results should be interpreted in light of the assumptions and limitations of the input data.

Applied SciencesVol. 16(22)
Yeungnam University (KR)
Industry, innovation and infrastructure
Occupational Health and Safety in Workplaces
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon