D4.2: Safety and durability of reusable packaging

Safety, durability, and functionality of reusable plastic food packaging (RPP) are critical for effective use cycles, sustainability, and waste prevention. From regulatory perspective, Packaging and Packaging Waste Regulation (PPWR) defines technical requirements necessary to classify packaging as reusable through EN 13429 standard. The European Commission Regulation No 10/2011 covers migration of substances from food contact materials intended for repeated use. However, there is a scientific and regulatory gap on material selection criteria against wear, exposure to hot caustic washing cycles with respect to migration and microplastic safety. This deliverable focuses on durability and safety of RPP against mechanical wear by cutlery and chemical ageing due to food contact and hot washing. Investigation covers performance of prevailing food contact plastics in RPP including Polybutylene Terephthalate (PBT), glass fibre reinforced PBT (PBT-GF), Tritan an amorphous copolyester, a homopolymer and three impact copolymer grades of Polypropylene (PP), and High-Density Polyethylene (HDPE). Reuse induced wear and scratch patterns are examined and quantified by microscopy of post-consumer RPP. Packaging comes in three formats namely single and double compartment trays, and pizza trays. Migration and microscopy results show that scratches per se do not compromise microplastic or migration safety. However, physical, and chemical analysis reveal notable microplastic leaching risk for polyesters such as PBT when similar scratches are applied on hot washed specimens. Risk enhances linearly as a function of washing cycles (15-100 cycles) due to hydrolytic degradation. PP does not impose microplastic risks per wash-scratch tests and therefore recommended. Interestingly, the characteristic spectroscopic fingerprint of all materials alters as a function of washing cycles. Therefore, spectroscopic scanning can be used as a non-contact high throughput method for tracking critical ageing limits, wash and use cycles of RPP. The microscopy analysis of post-consumer and aged packaging indicate higher microplastic risk due to scratches than wear. Therefore, double compartment RPP designs prohibiting use of sharp utensils are recommended from safetyperspective. The specific migration limits (SML) for PBT are not sensitive to post-consumer mimicked scratches, which is promising. The scratched PP failed to pass SML defined for 9,9-bis (methoxymethyl) fluorene (BMMF) a common catalyst used in PP polymerisation. Alternative catalyst should be considered for PP grades intended for RPP. Therefore, to ensure packaging remains safe during reuse, it is recommended to do migration tests on washed-scratched specimens. A methodology is proposed to replicate wide range of scratch geometries by parametric optimisation of instrumented diamond indenter. The findings enable mimicking various reuse scenarios to assess packaging performance and safety. The indentation, scratch, and tensile data is utilised to calibrate a numerical model with Abaqus software. Parameters representing deep scratches as a conservative scenario are used to assess scratch and wear resistance of plastics. Pearson correlation analysis of collected data shows that scratch resistance of plastics correlates with hardness and rigidity. The yield properties, especially elongation at yield promotes scratch recovery. PBT and PP copolymer with yield elongation over 11% offer highest scratch recovery. A design map is provided per by numerical analysis to predict scratch resistance of plastics in terms of indenter penetration depth as function of hardness and rigidity. It can be useful for material selection and preliminary assessment during RPP design. Reinforcing PBT with glass fibres notably enhance its rigidity, strength, and hardness. Therefore, PBT-GF has better wear and scratch resistance in terms of indentation depth than PBT. However, due to its brittle nature, PBT-GF has lower scratch recovery and deeper scratches compared to PBT. The hydrolytic stability of PBT against hot wash cycles does not improve by glass fibre reinforcement. Wear resistance in this study concerned aesthetic aspects, appeal, and glossiness rather than safety concern. The wear resistance of plastics, in terms of surface roughness after wear, correlated well with hardness and surface friction. Plastics with indentation hardness over 100 MPa and initial surface roughness less than 0.03 μm had best performance. It is foreseen that results, recommendations, analytical tools and methodologies developed in this deliverable will be valuable for ecodesign and safety assessment of RPP.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-12
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24166111
Primary Topic
Microplastics and Plastic Pollution
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

D4.2: Safety and durability of reusable packaging

Royson Donate Dsouza, Helena Ronkainen, Manu C. Mulakkal, Farzin Javanshour et al.
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Microplastics and Plastic Pollution
article

D4.2: Safety and durability of reusable packaging

Royson Donate Dsouza, Helena Ronkainen, Manu C. Mulakkal, Farzin Javanshour, Artur Korostavyi, Ursina Haslebacher, Yu Jiang
article en

Abstract

Safety, durability, and functionality of reusable plastic food packaging (RPP) are critical for effective use cycles, sustainability, and waste prevention. From regulatory perspective, Packaging and Packaging Waste Regulation (PPWR) defines technical requirements necessary to classify packaging as reusable through EN 13429 standard. The European Commission Regulation No 10/2011 covers migration of substances from food contact materials intended for repeated use. However, there is a scientific and regulatory gap on material selection criteria against wear, exposure to hot caustic washing cycles with respect to migration and microplastic safety. This deliverable focuses on durability and safety of RPP against mechanical wear by cutlery and chemical ageing due to food contact and hot washing. Investigation covers performance of prevailing food contact plastics in RPP including Polybutylene Terephthalate (PBT), glass fibre reinforced PBT (PBT-GF), Tritan an amorphous copolyester, a homopolymer and three impact copolymer grades of Polypropylene (PP), and High-Density Polyethylene (HDPE). Reuse induced wear and scratch patterns are examined and quantified by microscopy of post-consumer RPP. Packaging comes in three formats namely single and double compartment trays, and pizza trays. Migration and microscopy results show that scratches per se do not compromise microplastic or migration safety. However, physical, and chemical analysis reveal notable microplastic leaching risk for polyesters such as PBT when similar scratches are applied on hot washed specimens. Risk enhances linearly as a function of washing cycles (15-100 cycles) due to hydrolytic degradation. PP does not impose microplastic risks per wash-scratch tests and therefore recommended. Interestingly, the characteristic spectroscopic fingerprint of all materials alters as a function of washing cycles. Therefore, spectroscopic scanning can be used as a non-contact high throughput method for tracking critical ageing limits, wash and use cycles of RPP. The microscopy analysis of post-consumer and aged packaging indicate higher microplastic risk due to scratches than wear. Therefore, double compartment RPP designs prohibiting use of sharp utensils are recommended from safetyperspective. The specific migration limits (SML) for PBT are not sensitive to post-consumer mimicked scratches, which is promising. The scratched PP failed to pass SML defined for 9,9-bis (methoxymethyl) fluorene (BMMF) a common catalyst used in PP polymerisation. Alternative catalyst should be considered for PP grades intended for RPP. Therefore, to ensure packaging remains safe during reuse, it is recommended to do migration tests on washed-scratched specimens. A methodology is proposed to replicate wide range of scratch geometries by parametric optimisation of instrumented diamond indenter. The findings enable mimicking various reuse scenarios to assess packaging performance and safety. The indentation, scratch, and tensile data is utilised to calibrate a numerical model with Abaqus software. Parameters representing deep scratches as a conservative scenario are used to assess scratch and wear resistance of plastics. Pearson correlation analysis of collected data shows that scratch resistance of plastics correlates with hardness and rigidity. The yield properties, especially elongation at yield promotes scratch recovery. PBT and PP copolymer with yield elongation over 11% offer highest scratch recovery. A design map is provided per by numerical analysis to predict scratch resistance of plastics in terms of indenter penetration depth as function of hardness and rigidity. It can be useful for material selection and preliminary assessment during RPP design. Reinforcing PBT with glass fibres notably enhance its rigidity, strength, and hardness. Therefore, PBT-GF has better wear and scratch resistance in terms of indentation depth than PBT. However, due to its brittle nature, PBT-GF has lower scratch recovery and deeper scratches compared to PBT. The hydrolytic stability of PBT against hot wash cycles does not improve by glass fibre reinforcement. Wear resistance in this study concerned aesthetic aspects, appeal, and glossiness rather than safety concern. The wear resistance of plastics, in terms of surface roughness after wear, correlated well with hardness and surface friction. Plastics with indentation hardness over 100 MPa and initial surface roughness less than 0.03 μm had best performance. It is foreseen that results, recommendations, analytical tools and methodologies developed in this deliverable will be valuable for ecodesign and safety assessment of RPP.

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland (FI)
Responsible consumption and production
Microplastics and Plastic Pollution
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon